
Summary
A difficult goodbye can unsettle both a child and a mother. This article connects early development, attachment and differentiation of self with the experience of separation.
At a glance
Separation anxiety is a normal developmental experience in young children, while mothers may also feel worry, guilt or loss when apart from their child. Object permanence and a secure attachment help explain children's experience; maternal differentiation of self, temperament and social support also enter the discussion. Coping approaches should fit the child and circumstances, and professional assessment may be needed when anxiety is severe, has not begun to diminish after age four or five, or remains overwhelming despite these approaches; age alone is not a diagnosis.
At the start of the school year, the entrance to a kindergarten can sound like a chorus of heartbreak. Children sob as their mothers try every way they can think of to soothe them. Some mothers are fighting back tears themselves.
The scene captures an experience almost everyone knows: separation anxiety. Why does being apart cause such distress? How does that distress gradually fade as children grow? And why does it sometimes persist throughout life, becoming severe enough to develop into separation anxiety disorder?
To understand what happens at the kindergarten door, we need to consider both the child who is being left and the parent who has to leave.
How children learn that separation is temporary
In infancy and early childhood, separation anxiety refers to the anxiety, unease or distress that arises when a child is separated from loved ones. It is a normal stage of psychological development, commonly experienced between about six or seven months and three years of age.
One concept that helps explain it is object permanence, introduced by the child psychologist Jean Piaget. This is the understanding that something exists as an independent entity and continues to exist even when we cannot see or otherwise perceive it.
Imagine a child playing with a ball that rolls under the sofa. Before understanding object permanence, the child may believe the ball has disappeared. A parent's departure can be similarly bewildering: the infant does not yet understand that the separation is temporary, and the resulting crying can be desperate.
Piaget held that infants gradually develop object permanence at around 10 to 12 months. Yet children who have passed that age and can understand that an unseen person still exists may continue to experience separation anxiety. Object permanence therefore explains only part of the experience. Another concept is needed: attachment.
A secure base makes exploration possible
Harry Harlow's well-known experiments with infant rhesus monkeys explored the nature of attachment. The monkeys went to a wire surrogate mother when they needed milk, but otherwise returned to a cloth surrogate mother. The original Chinese article, “I Don’t Want to Leave You: Rethinking Separation Anxiety,” interprets these findings as showing that what truly matters in forming early attachment between infants and caregivers is contact comfort rather than the satisfaction of oral needs.
In subsequent open-field experiments, the young monkeys were more willing to explore an unfamiliar environment when the cloth mother was present. They repeatedly returned to her for reassurance. The caregiver had become a secure base: a source of safety from which they could venture out and to which they could return.
A familiar playground scene shows a similar pattern. A mother says, “Go and play. I'll be right here watching.” Her child plays for a while, then looks up to find her. Once their eyes meet, the child happily gets on with playing.
The child does not need to remain physically beside the mother at every moment. Knowing she is there, and that returning to her is possible, provides enough security to tolerate a brief separation. The safe harbor remains available even while the child explores.
As that secure base becomes firmly established within the child, longer absences can become easier too. The child comes to understand that being apart does not make the relationship or its safety disappear, and separation anxiety subsides.
For people who, for various reasons, do not establish this stable sense of security, separation anxiety may persist. In some cases, it can develop into separation anxiety disorder.
When separation anxiety becomes excessive
The definition attributed to the American Psychological Association describes excessive fear and distress when facing separation from home or certain related circumstances. What distinguishes the disorder is concern about being apart from a caregiver or family member that is excessive or inappropriate for the person's age.
Separation anxiety disorder is described as the most common anxiety disorder among children under 12, with estimates suggesting that it affects 4–5% of children and adolescents. It may continue into adulthood. It has also been described as a precursor to adult anxiety disorders and associated with depression during adolescence; these links do not mean that every affected child will follow that course.
The distress can extend beyond crying or fiercely resisting a goodbye. A child may refuse to attend school or sleep alone, have nightmares about separation, or experience disrupted sleep. Learning difficulties, problems with peers and difficulty regulating emotions may accompany these experiences.
If a child's anxiety is very severe, professional help may be needed. Another reason to seek help is separation anxiety that has not begun to diminish naturally after age four or five. These are reasons to have the situation assessed, rather than a diagnosis based on age alone.
Several influences may contribute to the disorder. Research has reported that approximately 73% of people diagnosed with adult separation anxiety disorder had a family psychiatric history. This concerns psychiatric history broadly, rather than necessarily the same disorder in relatives. Other research has suggested that environmental influences may be greater than genetic ones.
Stressful experiences can include the unexpected death of a loved one, being forced apart from someone important, or living in an unhealthy relationship. Biological factors also appear to play a role. The source then states that adults with separation anxiety disorder have an imbalance in brain neurotransmitters responsible for controlling and regulating emotions and impulses, and that this imbalance causes symptoms to emerge.
The picture is therefore broader than any single cause: family history, life circumstances and possible biological influences all enter the discussion.
The parent who leaves may be struggling too
Return to that first day of kindergarten. The child's distress is visible, but what does the separation feel like to the parents?
Amy, a first-time mother, described her first outing with friends after leaving her baby daughter at home. After 45 minutes, she could no longer concentrate on the conversation. All she could think about was going home to her daughter. When she returned, love overwhelmed her, and she cried as she held her baby.
A 2016 UK survey conducted by PACEY, a professional association for childcare and early years, together with a parenting website, asked 1,000 mothers about their feelings. Seventy percent said they worried about missing their children. Ninety percent reported feeling anxious about returning to work after childbirth, and nearly half described themselves as very anxious. These were reports of feelings among the respondents, rather than rates of diagnosed separation anxiety disorder.
Historically, infant separation anxiety attracted considerable research attention, while mothers' feelings during the same separations received much less. According to the source article, that imbalance had begun to improve only in the years preceding its publication.
Maternal separation anxiety refers to negative emotions associated with being apart from one's child. Those feelings may include loss, worry, guilt or a sense of rejection.
Why might the experience be more difficult for some mothers than others? One important part of the explanation concerns a mother's sense of herself.
Staying connected while remaining a separate person
Research identifies a mother's sense of self as an important influence on the degree of separation anxiety she experiences. In this discussion, that sense of self is understood through differentiation of self, a concept from Murray Bowen's family systems theory.
Differentiation has two main dimensions. In relationships, it concerns the ability to become emotionally and physically separate from one's family of origin and achieve mature independence while retaining the capacity for emotional connection. Within the individual, it concerns the ability to distinguish thinking from feeling.
With a well-established sense of self, a person can recognize that losing someone, or being separated from them, does not mean losing oneself. A mother whose sense of self is less firmly established may find it harder to experience herself and her child as separate people. That can make balancing her own needs with her child's needs more difficult.
Research has found a positive correlation between mothers' separation anxiety and their children's anxiety levels. Children's separation anxiety has also been negatively correlated with maternal differentiation of self. Lower maternal differentiation has been associated with higher anxiety in both mother and child.
These relationships do not, by themselves, establish a one-way cause. A baby's temperament and the social support available to the mother also influence maternal separation anxiety.
Some anxiety about leaving a child is normal. When it becomes excessive, however, it can harm parents' mental health and affect parenting behavior and children's development.
One study found that mothers with high separation anxiety were overly sensitive to their infants' negative emotions and that this excessive sensitivity caused the infants' positive social signals to go without appropriate, timely responses. Other research has proposed that separation anxiety leads mothers to experience separation as a threat and respond with more protective behavior. This can hinder separation–individuation: the process through which a child develops a more independent sense of self.
These are proposed patterns through which excessive anxiety can affect a relationship, rather than a description of every mother who finds a goodbye difficult.
Making separations more manageable
Counseling resources offer several practical approaches for helping young children cope. Examples include:
- Establishing a simple goodbye ritual and telling the child exactly when you will return and what you are leaving to do.
- Playing peekaboo to help the child develop an understanding of object permanence.
- Staying calm before leaving and keeping the goodbye brief and clear.
- Redirecting the child's attention toward something to look forward to at kindergarten.
These are starting points. The most useful approach depends on the particular situation and the child's temperament. Finding what suits your child matters more than treating any one suggestion as a universal answer.
Parents' own emotional responses also deserve attention. Parents should first ensure that their own anxiety is not excessive; only then can they reduce the negative emotions they pass on to their child.
For parents, counselors suggest first recognizing what you feel, talking with other parents and redirecting your attention. Beyond these coping techniques, the research on differentiation points toward the value of developing a healthy, independent sense of self. Only after learning to maintain an independent sense of self can a mother gradually learn to let go in her relationship with her child.
If these approaches do not adequately ease your anxiety or your child's, seek professional help. You do not have to keep trying to manage an overwhelming experience on your own.
Perhaps you remember the distress of separation from your own childhood. Perhaps an adult experience has brought back that same piercing pain. You may have found yourself unable to settle into work long after leaving your child, or noticed moments when accepting your child as a completely separate person still feels difficult.
Recognizing those feelings is already a first step toward change. Give yourself room to acknowledge and express them. Feelings that have gone unnoticed for a long time can finally receive attention when they are spoken.
Frequently asked questions
Why can separation anxiety continue after object permanence develops?
Object permanence explains only part of separation anxiety. A child may understand that an unseen parent still exists while still needing reassurance that the relationship remains safe and the caregiver is available as a secure base.
What is maternal separation anxiety?
Maternal separation anxiety refers to negative emotions associated with being apart from one's child. These may include loss, worry, guilt or a sense of rejection. Some anxiety is normal; excessive anxiety can affect parents' mental health and parenting.
Does a mother's anxiety cause her child's separation anxiety?
Research described in the article reports correlations between maternal anxiety, child anxiety and maternal differentiation of self. These relationships do not establish a one-way cause. A baby's temperament and the social support available to the mother also matter.
What may help children cope with separation?
Examples include a simple goodbye ritual, explaining exactly when the parent will return and why they are leaving, playing peekaboo, staying calm, keeping goodbyes brief and redirecting attention toward something enjoyable at kindergarten. The approach should fit the child's temperament and circumstances; these suggestions are not universal solutions.
When should families seek professional help for separation anxiety?
Professional help may be needed when a child's anxiety is very severe or has not begun to diminish naturally after age four or five. Age alone does not establish a diagnosis. Seek help as well if coping approaches do not adequately ease the parent's or child's anxiety.


