
Summary
Facing a mistake may feel less threatening when self-worth is stable. The researchers explore how self-compassion could reduce the urge to defend wrongdoing and make room for responsibility and repair.
At a glance
The researchers report that greater self-compassion was associated with less unethical behavior in samples of 222 adults and 3,236 adolescents. They propose that stable self-worth helps people acknowledge mistakes with less defensive rationalization, reducing moral disengagement. Both samples reportedly supported this proposed mediating role.
Treating others badly may sometimes have roots in how people treat themselves. That possibility raises a question for researchers studying self-compassion: do people who show themselves more compassion also engage in less unethical behavior?
Their reasoning begins with a distinction between self-compassion and self-centeredness. One core element of self-compassion, common humanity, means recognizing that everyone has shortcomings and encounters failure. From this perspective, everyone deserves care and kindness, including both oneself and other people.
The researchers report that their own work and findings from other researchers show significant positive associations between caring for oneself and caring for others across values, emotions, and behavior. These include perspective-taking—the ability to consider another person's point of view—as well as empathic concern, altruistic traits, and prosocial behavior. They reason that greater attention to other people's feelings and interests should make someone less willing to pursue personal gain at another person's expense.
Self-compassion may also affect how people respond to their own wrongdoing. The researchers distinguish it from self-indulgence: in their account, it provides a more stable sense of self-worth. Its mindfulness component helps people face their shortcomings with less avoidance and resistance, allowing them to learn from mistakes and limitations. They cite prior research reporting that, when confronting moral transgressions, self-compassion helps people remain emotionally stable while acknowledging their shortcomings and reflecting on what they did wrong.
From this, they reason that people with greater self-compassion are less tolerant of their own moral errors, more willing to take responsibility, and more motivated to correct their behavior and make amends. The capacity to face wrongdoing and work to repair it gives them another reason to predict that self-compassion may reduce unethical tendencies.
How might this process work when someone recognizes a mistake? The researchers offer an imagined situation. A student is interning at a company as an office assistant, regularly handling tasks such as printing documents. One day, needing to prepare job-application materials and having run out of printing paper at home, the student takes a stack of office paper home.
Nobody knows about it, but the student feels that taking the paper was wrong, like stealing company property. What might they do next?
The researchers suggest that a student with greater self-compassion may be better able to notice, accept, and face the mistake, leaving room to make amends. They might think, “Taking the paper was wrong. I'll return it tomorrow.”
A student lacking self-compassion might instead feel that the act threatens their image of themselves as a moral person and rush to ease the discomfort: “The paper is for everyone, so taking some is fine,” or “It seems I'm not the only one who's taken company paper home.” In this imagined response, the student reaches for excuses that make the action easier to defend.
In the researchers' interpretation, difficulty facing the mistake prompts rationalization. The excuses relieve the threat to the student's moral self-image by allowing them to avoid acknowledging what they did wrong. That avoidance may, in turn, lead to further unethical behavior.
This process is called moral disengagement: reinterpreting one's unethical behavior in ways that make it seem morally justified and acceptable to oneself. The researchers describe it as a self-serving defense that reduces the threat wrongdoing poses to a person's moral identity. Rationalizing the behavior preserves a positive moral self-image, makes guilt and self-reproach less likely, and allows people to avoid seeing themselves as immoral. They report that a large body of research identifies moral disengagement as the strongest factor driving people to engage in unethical behavior.
Self-compassion, they propose, can interrupt this defense by encouraging more objective self-evaluation and fewer self-serving explanations for wrongdoing. Stable self-worth gives people what they describe as a “stronger” self: a greater capacity to acknowledge mistakes rather than evade or soften threats to their moral identity.
Their hypothesis follows a specific sequence. Self-compassion reduces defensive rationalization, making moral-disengagement strategies less likely to be activated or used. This, in turn, may reduce unethical behavior. Moral disengagement is therefore their proposed mediator—the process through which self-compassion might influence unethical behavior.
To test this hypothesis, the researchers conducted two studies: Study 1 involved 222 adults, and Study 2 involved 3,236 adolescents. They report that both samples supported a negative relationship between self-compassion and unethical behavior: greater self-compassion was associated with less unethical behavior. Both samples also supported a mediating role for moral disengagement.
The researchers interpret these findings as evidence that self-compassion reduces unethical behavior by reducing moral disengagement. They regard the results as further support for their earlier hypothesis that self-compassion has positive social functions.
Looking across their wider series of studies, they report that self-compassion can improve psychological well-being, strengthen interpersonal connections, encourage positive social behavior, and reduce unethical actions that harm others and society. They also see their work as offering an explanation, centered on how people relate to themselves, for why some repeatedly defend their bad behavior.
Their practical recommendation is self-compassion training, including a simple suggestion: after making a mistake, try responding to yourself with the kindness you would offer a friend who needed comfort. In their view, this practice could enrich both your own life and the lives of others by improving psychological functioning, supporting more harmonious relationships, and helping you face mistakes and develop greater inner strength.
Frequently asked questions
What is moral disengagement?
Moral disengagement means reinterpreting one's unethical behavior in ways that make it seem morally justified and acceptable to oneself. The researchers describe it as a defense that protects a positive moral self-image.
What did the two studies report?
The researchers report that samples of 222 adults and 3,236 adolescents both supported an association between greater self-compassion and less unethical behavior, along with a mediating role for moral disengagement.
How do the researchers suggest practicing self-compassion after a mistake?
They suggest responding to yourself with the kindness you would offer a friend who needed comfort. In their account, this may help people face mistakes and develop greater inner strength.

