
Summary
Compassion, everyday spiritual aims and active investigation receive greater emphasis in second-generation mindfulness programs, while research support remains uneven across their components.
At a glance
Second-generation mindfulness-based interventions broaden earlier programs through additional Buddhist-derived practices, more explicit ethical and spiritual aims, and active investigation of experience. They retain a secular framework without requiring religious belief. Rigorous comparisons with earlier interventions remain very rare, so positive overall findings do not establish superiority or equivalence.
Mindfulness meditation originated in Buddhist practice, but psychology has adopted and promoted it as a practice requiring no religious belief. Its use has become widespread in China and internationally. During the pandemic, China’s National Health Commission reportedly recommended mindfulness meditation as a method of emotional regulation.
Its applications have widened beyond relaxation, stress reduction, and clinically oriented work with anxiety and depression. Mindfulness interventions have increasingly been used with the aim of improving well-being and work efficiency, as well as supporting interpersonal and parent–child relationships. These are areas of application, rather than evidence that the intended benefits occur in every setting.
Alongside this expansion, the content and guiding ideas of mindfulness interventions have changed. These developments have given rise to what are called second-generation mindfulness-based interventions, a newer direction in applied psychology.
Broader practices and aims
The changes fall into three intertwined dimensions: course content, aims, and the understanding of mindfulness itself. The comparison here is with earlier or classical interventions, including acceptance and commitment therapy and an approach described as “introspective cognitive therapy”.
The most visible change is broader content. Where classical programs center on mindfulness, second-generation programs incorporate additional practices and ideas from Buddhist traditions: compassion meditation, emptiness meditation, and discussion of the “three poisons”—greed, aversion, and delusion. These remain secular psychology courses, without religious commitments or transcendent content such as rebirth.
Compassion meditation already has a small place in classical interventions. In second-generation programs, it takes a much larger role and can occupy a greater share of the course than mindfulness meditation itself, though the balance varies across programs.
The aims broaden along with the practices. Second-generation interventions more explicitly seek to cultivate a broadly spiritual way of living day to day within their secular framework. Their purpose extends beyond teaching psychological techniques for regulating emotions.
This orientation brings ethics, particularly compassion, into more explicit discussion. Part of the rationale is to guard against interpreting “nonjudgment” as abandoning principles or losing any distinction between right and wrong. This is a concern about how the teaching might be understood, rather than an inevitable consequence of practicing mindfulness. Earlier interventions can also strengthen prosocial attitudes, and teaching mindfulness alone does not necessarily lead to unethical behavior. The distinction lies in how explicitly the newer programs make ethics part of the practice.
Awareness and active investigation
The third change concerns what mindfulness itself includes. Relatively passive, nonjudgmental awareness remains a foundation, but this broader conception adds active investigation, potentially including judgment and analysis. Noticing experience is still central; practice also involves attending to its characteristics.
The distinction is abstract and involves complex mental operations in advanced practice. A simple illustration is noticing feelings accurately while also observing how they continually change and what gives rise to them. In the original writer’s interpretation, this more active understanding comes closer to mindfulness meditation in Buddhist traditions than earlier, simplified psychological versions. The illustration offers a way into the distinction; the advanced operations involved lie beyond the discussion here.
Representative programs and research
The writer credits Van Gordon and colleagues with proposing the concept of second-generation mindfulness-based interventions in 2015, identifying two representative programs at the time.
One was Meditation Awareness Training (MAT), developed by Van Gordon and colleagues themselves and widely applied across clinical and subclinical populations (Van Gordon et al., 2014). The other, Mindfulness-Based Positive Behavior Support (MBPBS), has been used more commonly with parents and caregivers to support them in raising adolescents and caring for patients (Singh et al., 2014). The 2014 citations concern these programs; the conceptual proposal followed in 2015. Other interventions drawing on the newer ideas have also emerged internationally in recent years.
The writer assesses the outcomes of second-generation interventions as positive overall, while emphasizing that rigorous comparisons with classical interventions remain very rare. The generations also differ in their purposes and orientation, which needs to be kept in view when considering comparisons. This assessment does not establish that the newer programs are superior to, or equivalent to, earlier ones.
Research examines both complete programs and the individual practices and concepts they incorporate. Among the components discussed here, the writer identifies compassion meditation as the most extensively studied, with the greatest research support for positive effects. Greater research support does not establish that it is the most effective component. Ethics and emptiness meditation have also received preliminary research attention, but studies remain few.

