
Summary
Suppliers in Luang Prabang valued local authenticity but faced commercial constraints. At Stirling Castle, personalized 3D-printed souvenirs prompted interest alongside differing views about participation and price.
At a glance
Souvenirs can represent visited places, people and events, helping travelers recall their experiences. Two 2019 studies explore suppliers’ commitments to local authenticity and the potential for 3D printing to involve tourists in production. Personalization and participation can add experiential value for some tourists, but interest does not establish purchases or willingness to pay more.
What are tourists buying when they buy a souvenir, beyond the physical object itself? Two articles published in Tourism Management in 2019 approach that question from different directions: one examines suppliers’ understandings of authenticity, while the other explores how participating in production might change a souvenir’s value.
B. Soukhathammavong and E. Park investigate the supplier perspective in “The authentic souvenir: What does it mean to souvenir suppliers in the heritage destination?” (Tourism Management, volume 72, pages 105–116). C. Anastasiadou and S. Vettese consider digital fabrication in “‘From souvenirs to 3D printed souvenirs’. Exploring the capabilities of additive manufacturing technologies in (re)-framing tourist souvenirs.” (Tourism Management, volume 71, pages 428–442).
Authenticity matters because a souvenir can represent the places travelers have visited, the people they have met and the events they have experienced. After the trip, it helps bring those experiences back to mind. Earlier research has mostly considered authenticity from tourists’ perspectives, usually linking it to a destination’s culture, heritage and local identity, or to what makes particular events and activities distinctive.
Within that literature, a souvenir’s place of origin, handmade production and use of local materials are associated with objectivist authenticity. Uniqueness, aesthetic qualities, appealing materials and design, and higher prices tend to be associated with constructivist interpretations. These offer different ways of understanding authenticity rather than mutually exclusive categories.
Yet what tourists want and buy also depends partly on suppliers. Soukhathammavong and Park examined suppliers’ perceptions in Luang Prabang, Laos, a World Heritage destination described in the study as experiencing rapid tourism development because of its distinctive culture. Their research covered four groups: retailers, producers, vendors and intermediaries.
The suppliers associated authenticity with culture, history and local identity; local handmade production; uniqueness and attractiveness; and the skilled craftsmanship of local artisans. They placed particular weight on a souvenir’s local origins, seeking the objective authenticity described above. Knowing what made a souvenir authentic, however, did not ensure that they could put those commitments into practice.
In the Luang Prabang study, shortages of capital and knowledge made it difficult for local producers to compete with imported, mass-produced merchandise in production and price. Seeking profit, producers preferred to spend time selling those imports rather than making products themselves. Suppliers also faced shortages of raw materials and locally made products, competition from foreign traders, and insufficient control over production. These pressures encouraged them to increase volume for profit and sell mass-produced goods imported from China and elsewhere, diminishing the authenticity they valued.
The broader argument connecting the two studies treats this tension as widespread in souvenir sales involving local communities. Conventional souvenirs must negotiate authenticity rooted in place while facing difficulties with raw materials, transportation, storage, price, quality and uniqueness. Anastasiadou and Vettese’s article approaches the question from another direction: what might change if tourists helped make the objects they take home?
The contrast is between static objects designed by others for tourists to buy and collect, leaving them as passive consumers, and a more participatory experience. 3D printing and open-source digital fabrication facilities could enable immersive co-creation, moving tourists from the margins of material production toward its center. This possibility changes how a souvenir might be experienced, though it does not establish that local economic pressures or difficulties in sustaining authenticity have been resolved.
Anastasiadou and Vettese conducted empirical research at Stirling Castle in the United Kingdom, examining tourists’ attitudes and the possibilities and challenges of producing and consuming 3D-printed souvenirs in a heritage setting. Responses varied. Some respondents disliked souvenir shopping, and personalization through 3D printing held no appeal for them. Some feared that the technology would deprive local communities of benefits from souvenir production. Others considered well-made handicrafts more valuable than 3D-printed goods.
Despite these reservations, 87.7% of respondents expressed interest in the personalized customization that 3D printing could offer. Interest did not establish whether they would buy such a souvenir or pay more for it. Some felt that the objects on display were not special enough to justify a higher price. Others would pay more if the objects could be personalized further. For another group, contributing to the design and investing their own time meant they should pay less.
These differences extend the question of value beyond the finished object. Earlier research had identified craftsmanship and material quality, local production, craft and customization, and exclusivity as factors influencing souvenir purchases. Anastasiadou and Vettese’s study identified additional factors as important influences on purchase intention: participating in making the souvenir, engaging more closely with the object encountered during the visit, investing time in the souvenir, and the degree of customization and personalization. Tourists’ own contributions could enter their judgments of price in different ways.
The experiential interpretation developed here is that 3D printing can offer aesthetic and emotional experiences through which tourists develop their own sense of personalization and authenticity. Participation can be simple. The Stirling Castle study reports that choosing a souvenir’s color or size, or watching it being printed, can move tourists from consumers toward co-designers and “prosumers”—people who take part in producing what they consume. For some tourists, this involvement creates a closer emotional connection with the place they have visited. The souvenir’s significance then includes the experience of its design and production.
Turning these possibilities into marketable souvenirs still faces clear obstacles. As 3D printing becomes more widespread, its novelty for tourists is expected to fade. Possible problems involving efficiency, intellectual property and other practical issues also complicate commercialization.
Technological development and mobility expand opportunities for shopping, consumption and experience during travel, while potentially challenging the concept of authenticity at the heart of tourist shopping. How the different actors within production and consumption systems create and negotiate the value and experiences that souvenirs offer remains a question for further tourism research.
Frequently asked questions
What does the reported 87.7% figure mean?
In the Stirling Castle study, 87.7% of respondents expressed interest in personalization through 3D printing. This did not establish whether they would buy a souvenir or pay more for it.
Why did local authenticity prove difficult to sustain in Luang Prabang?
The supplier study described shortages of capital, knowledge, raw materials and locally made products, alongside competition from foreign traders and insufficient control over production. These pressures encouraged selling imported, mass-produced goods despite suppliers’ commitments to local authenticity.
Did participation make tourists willing to pay more?
Views differed. Some respondents would pay more for further personalization, while others believed that contributing design work and time meant they should pay less.

