
Summary
Two unhappy partners may each stay because they fear the other would be devastated by separation. The article examines how consideration can support a relationship yet also prolong one that suits neither person.
At a glance
Leaving can feel difficult because of past investment, fear of loneliness, and concern for a partner. Research described by Samantha Joel and colleagues suggests that believing a partner depends on the relationship or would suffer after a breakup can discourage leaving, even when someone is unhappy. These beliefs concern perceived needs and anticipated pain; they do not establish what the partner actually wants or would experience.
For someone who is single, watching couples together can stir envy and the question of when it will finally be their turn. Some of those couples might find that envy ironic. From inside a difficult relationship, romance can feel like a burden, and having a partner may hardly seem like something to celebrate.
A loving, harmonious relationship is easy to want. A painful one can leave someone feeling trapped and powerless, even when their partner causes them unbearable emotional distress. Consider someone whose friends keep urging them to leave: “They treat you terribly. Why are you still together?” or “You’re not right for each other. Can’t you see that?” The person may agree that the advice makes sense and still be unable to summon the courage to end the relationship. What stands between recognizing how much a relationship hurts and deciding to leave it?
Some possible reasons are familiar. After investing so much time, effort, and emotion, ending a relationship can feel like accepting an enormous loss. Leaving also means losing companionship. If being single seems even harder to bear, an unsatisfying relationship may feel preferable to having no relationship at all.
These explanations focus on what leaving would cost the person making the decision. Seen that way, difficulty breaking up can look like cowardice or an unwillingness to bear personal losses. But a relationship involves two people, and the decision may turn on concern for the other person as well. Research by Samantha Joel and colleagues at the University of Utah suggests that consideration for a partner can play a decisive role in whether someone chooses to leave.
The original article’s writer contrasts such consideration with an economic view of self-interest maximization, characterized as seeking the greatest benefit for oneself and the least for others. Psychological research, however, suggests that people do not invariably act with such cold calculation. They can consider other people’s interests and make choices that benefit them.
Interdependence Theory offers a way to understand this in romantic relationships. Partners interact frequently, and in this theoretical account, a lasting relationship cannot be sustained by each person attending exclusively to their own interests. Shared experiences and a willingness to consider each other help build the relationship. What happens between them matters alongside what each person wants individually.
In a separate psychology experiment, participants were asked to recall something their partner had done badly, describe their imagined response, and remember how they had actually responded. When researchers compared the accounts, the imagined responses were more destructive than the responses participants recalled making.
The writer interprets this gap as suggesting that even intense anger, including fantasies of lashing out physically, can give way to a more considerate response. People may take their partner’s feelings into account and act in ways that protect the relationship, forgoing the immediate satisfaction of venting their anger. In this reading, a partner’s feelings enter decisions alongside the person’s own wishes.
That still leaves a question about motives. Someone might argue that caring for a partner ultimately serves personal interests: people want things they value from a relationship, and treating a partner considerately may help preserve those benefits. This explanation may account for some caring behavior without explaining all of it.
Joel and colleagues’ research suggests that concern for a partner can itself make someone reluctant to leave. In decisions to continue a low-quality relationship, how much people believed their partner needed the relationship played a clearly greater role than their own satisfaction or sense of security within it.
Two considerations mattered: perceiving the partner as committed to the relationship and expecting that a breakup would cause them substantial pain. The more someone believed their partner depended on the relationship, the stronger their wish to preserve it—even when they no longer depended on it themselves. In the reported findings, this pattern was unaffected by gender or how long the relationship had lasted. People could give their partner’s perceived needs priority over their own reasons for staying.
The researchers also noted that people differ in their motivation to meet another person’s needs. Someone less inclined to consider others’ feelings may be less sensitive to a partner’s needs, so this concern does not shape everyone’s decision in the same way.
Is giving so much weight to a partner’s needs necessarily good for the relationship? The writer offers a mixed assessment. For couples who have recently gotten together, mutual consideration can help them adjust to each other and build a more stable relationship. When the relationship suits neither person, however, that same instinctive concern can leave both stuck, unable to move forward together or bring themselves to separate.
Expectations about the pain of leaving may contribute to this stalemate. Earlier research suggests that people tend to overestimate how much distress they would feel after a breakup. Joel raises a related possibility: people might also overestimate how much their partner would suffer.
Imagine two partners, A and B, who are both privately unhappy with their relationship. A believes that B would be devastated by a breakup; B believes that A would fall apart. Each chooses to stay to spare the other that pain. In this hypothetical situation, concern for each other becomes a trap, keeping both in a relationship neither wants.
Trying to spare each other pain can also change how partners behave while they stay. Consider a couple who regret every argument and resolve to lose their tempers less. Gradually, avoiding conflict becomes avoiding conversation: neither dares to speak for fear of another fight. A cold war takes hold. The relationship grows more fragile, leaving both unsure how to proceed and struggling to find any of its former sweetness.
Joel distinguishes between maintaining a relationship by trying to avoid hurting a partner and maintaining it by actively creating positive shared experiences that strengthen affection. In her account, staying out of fear of causing pain may encourage the first approach. A partner may then feel that they are not being loved sincerely, and the effort to spare their feelings can end up hurting them more.
For the writer, letting go can sometimes be a final expression of affection. When a relationship has become deeply troubled and cannot be repaired, it is worth pausing to consider what both people actually want, rather than letting instinctive concern alone keep an unhappy partnership going. Sometimes, ending the relationship may be the better way to give both a chance to be free.
Frequently asked questions
Can concern for a partner make it harder to break up?
Joel and colleagues’ research suggests that concern for a partner can itself make someone reluctant to leave. The relevant considerations include perceived partner commitment and the expectation that a breakup would cause substantial pain.
Do people overestimate how much a breakup would hurt their partner?
Earlier research described in the article concerns overestimating one's own breakup distress. Joel proposes that people might also overestimate their partner's distress; this extension is presented as a possibility.
Does the article recommend ending every unhappy relationship?
The writer's closing suggestion applies when a relationship has become deeply troubled and cannot be repaired. In that situation, considering what both people actually want may make separation a better option for both.


