The Quiet Omen / Stress and Attention

Why Repeated Fundraising Appeals Can Make People Seem Indifferent

Repeated fundraising appeals can blunt sympathy. Explore compassion collapse, emotional burden, and why clear individual appeals may still fall short.

Explore this hub Psychology
An emotionally strained adult faces one clear request for help while several people wait farther away.

Summary

Why might one person's appeal evoke more sympathy than several people's requests? The discussion connects emotional regulation and individual clarity, then considers the limits of repeated fundraising appeals.

At a glance

Repeated fundraising appeals may contribute to compassion collapse, a decline in sympathy when multiple people request help. Proposed explanations include regulating emotionally draining feelings and difficulty picturing each person distinctly. The author interprets this response as self-protection against overwhelming emotional burden rather than evidence of diminished concern, while noting that frequent appeals to the same audience can undermine even clear, individual appeals.

Fundraising appeals from various platforms circulate through social feeds, shared and forwarded by friends. Some people continue to donate. For others, the impulse to help whenever they can gives way to irritation as the requests keep coming. Why can repeated appeals make people seem increasingly indifferent—and does that reaction mean they care less?

People often expect to feel more sympathy when they see more people suffering. Yet research has found that as the number of people asking for help grows, emotional responses can become blunted: sympathy may stop increasing and instead decline.

Whether those suffering ask for help matters. When victims did not request help, participants reported greater sympathy as the number of victims increased. When victims did ask for help, participants reported significantly less sympathy for eight victims than for one. Researchers call this decline in sympathy toward multiple people requesting help compassion collapse.

One proposed explanation concerns how people manage emotionally draining feelings. Researchers suggest that situations evoking strong sympathy may lead people to regulate their emotions to avoid excessive depletion. Under this hypothesis, people who show compassion collapse are likely to have used emotion-regulation strategies, while those whose sympathy does not collapse may not have used them.

To test this hypothesis, Daryl Cameron and Keith Payne, researchers at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, randomly assigned participants to two groups. Participants read material and viewed pictures about refugees, reporting how much sympathy they felt at different points in time. One group was instructed to evaluate the material as objectively as possible, without bringing in their own subjective feelings. The other was asked to fully experience the emotions of the people depicted.

When the material concerned one refugee, both groups reported increasing sympathy over time. When it concerned eight refugees, sympathy in the emotion-regulation group did not increase over time, and the account reports compassion collapse. The group instructed to experience the depicted people's emotions did not show compassion collapse.

The original author interprets this pattern as a protective response: when several people ask for help, people regulate their feelings to avoid becoming overly drained, and that regulation may in turn produce compassion collapse.

Emotional burden is only one part of the discussion. Separate research has found that compassion collapse can also occur when the people seeking help are represented indistinctly. How clearly someone comes into view as an individual may therefore matter alongside how people manage their feelings.

Think of scenes that have stirred especially strong sympathy in you. Are they also scenes that have stayed in your memory? The author invites this reflection through three images: an image of hunger in Sudan, an image of a little boy on a beach, and a Project Hope image featuring large eyes.

Bringing these strands together, the author suggests that a single person seeking help is easier to picture clearly. That clarity makes it easier to imagine being in the person's situation, feel sympathy and offer help. An individual appeal also tends to create less emotional depletion, making sympathy and assistance more likely.

When several people ask for help, each person may become harder to picture distinctly, while the emotional burden on a potential helper can feel excessive. Together, these factors may make compassion collapse more likely and weaken the willingness to help. In the author's interpretation, this response does not establish that human concern has diminished; it reflects a necessary form of self-protection against an overwhelming emotional burden.

That interpretation also informs the author's discussion of fundraising practices. Some fundraising websites already try to reduce compassion collapse by focusing on one person, presenting that person more clearly, and making an emotionally moving appeal without putting pressure on the audience. Even with these strategies, however, fundraisers who frequently send appeals to the same audience can still trigger compassion collapse.

Frequently asked questions

Does sympathy always decrease when more people are suffering?

No. In the reported research, participants expressed greater sympathy as victim numbers increased when victims did not request help. When victims requested help, participants reported significantly less sympathy for eight victims than for one.

Can individual fundraising appeals still trigger compassion collapse?

The author notes that frequent appeals to the same audience can still trigger compassion collapse, even when fundraisers clearly portray one person and make an emotionally moving appeal without pressuring the audience.