The Quiet Omen / Repeated Experiences

Why Giving Can Keep You Happier Than Buying for Yourself

Explore why giving can sustain happiness through repetition, what two experiments found, and how spending on others may strengthen social connection.

Explore this hub Symbolic Life
Two friends share a potted plant in a modern apartment, illustrating giving and social connection.

Summary

The pleasure of a purchase can fade with repetition. Research on repeated giving, charitable winnings and social connection offers another place to look for happiness.

At a glance

Giving may sustain happiness because it directs attention toward others and strengthens social connection. In one experiment, happiness remained at its initial level across five days of spending on others; in a ten-round game, happiness declined less when winnings benefited charity than when they benefited participants themselves. These findings suggest greater resistance to repetition, rather than establishing happiness that lasts indefinitely.

Shopping and eating something delicious can leave us feeling deeply satisfied. But can that happiness last indefinitely?

Usually, it cannot. The first taste of a wonderful meal or the first encounter with an unfamiliar experience often brings a particular kind of delight. Repeat it, and the feeling tends to lose its intensity. Without something fresh to discover, what once made us happy can gradually become boring. We get less happiness from each repetition, then start looking for the next new thing.

Giving offers a different possibility: helping someone feels good, and continuing to help can keep that feeling alive.

What happens when we keep giving?

Research has long shown that getting something can make us happy, whether it is good food or an unexpected windfall. Altruistic acts, such as giving gifts or donating to charity, can also lift our spirits. Both kinds of happiness are real. The striking contrast is that the pleasure of getting tends to fade, while the pleasure of helping seems to offer happiness without end.

Research has also found that people feel happier when they spend a windfall on others rather than on themselves. A study published in Psychological Science in February 2019 explored the persistence of this happiness through two experiments.

In the first, participants received $5 each day. One group had to spend the money on themselves, perhaps by buying a drink. The other had to spend it on someone else, whether by buying a gift for a particular person or donating to a charity. Both groups repeated their assigned kind of spending each day. At the end of every day, participants reported where the money had gone and how they had felt overall that day.

The groups began with similar levels of happiness. As participants repeatedly bought things for themselves, however, their happiness gradually declined. Among those spending on others, happiness remained at its initial level across the reported five days of repeated spending.

The second experiment approached the question through a game. Participants played ten rounds, with the game designed to make a win highly likely in each round. Every win earned five cents. Half the participants won the money for themselves; the other half won it for a charity. After each round, they rated how they felt about winning.

After the first round, happiness was approximately equal in the two groups. Over successive rounds, the happiness of those winning for themselves declined. That decline was much larger than the decline among those winning for charity.

The experiments suggest that repetition does not wear away the pleasure of helping as readily as it wears away the pleasure of getting. And beyond its staying power, simply buying something for another person can be a happy experience in its own right.

The emotional rewards of spending on others

Research links prosocial behavior—actions that benefit other people—with a sense of meaning and efficacy: the feeling that our actions can make a difference. It can also help people cope with negative emotions such as anxiety and loneliness, while increasing happiness.

A nationally representative American study by Dunn, Aknin and Norton, published in Science, examined the relationship between spending and happiness. Participants rated their happiness and reported their monthly spending in four categories: ordinary personal expenses, such as transportation and food; gifts for themselves; gifts for others; and charitable donations.

The researchers combined the first two categories into personal spending and the latter two into prosocial spending. Personal spending was unrelated to happiness in this survey. After accounting for income, people who devoted more money to prosocial spending reported more happy emotional experiences.

The emotional benefits of giving also extend beyond an American cultural setting. More than 600 university students in Canada and Uganda, an East African country, reported feeling very happy when recalling occasions on which they had spent money on others. The emotional benefit was consistent across these markedly different cultural settings, even though the ways participants spent their money differed substantially.

Brain imaging offers another perspective on these rewards. In an fMRI study involving donations to a local charity, each participant began with a $100 account. Those in a compulsory-donation group were shown a button to confirm the donation and another button that did nothing. Those in a voluntary-donation group could either confirm or refuse.

Even compulsory donations activated brain regions similar to those activated by receiving a reward. Alongside the findings about reported happiness, this suggests that the emotional rewards of prosocial giving can also be detected at the neural level.

There is a familiar sentiment in a Chinese song: if everyone gives a little love, the world becomes a better place. The research adds a personal dimension to that thought. Giving helps others, and the giver benefits too.

Why giving can feel so good

Why are we willing to give? What makes spending money on someone else emotionally rewarding?

The central explanation is connection. Humans are the most social animals on the planet. Almost anything we do to improve our connections with others can increase our happiness, including how we spend our money.

Diener and Seligman emphasize that strong social relationships are crucial to happiness, and that prosocial spending can have a remarkably powerful influence on those relationships.

Gifts are one way of maintaining a bond. One study found that receiving gifts from a partner benefits the long-term continuation of a relationship and significantly affects the likelihood that the relationship will eventually lead to marriage.

Spending money on friends or partners can express affection and romance. It also offers an opportunity for positive self-presentation—to show something positive about ourselves to another person. Both have been linked to emotional benefits.

Perhaps the ever-growing number of holidays makes a little more sense in that light. Each one gives us another occasion to give.

A different place to look for happiness

The freshness in giving comes from its focus on another person. When we acquire something for ourselves, our attention turns inward. With time and repetition, the experience becomes less interesting. We adjust to what was new and begin wanting something newer still.

Giving turns our attention outward. The experience of giving strengthens our social connections, and that connection can lift our mood. It may take only an expression of thanks, a thoughtful gift or a charitable donation.

The next time you want to create a little happiness—or feel like spending money but cannot decide what to buy—try stepping outside the question, “What am I missing?” Ask instead, “What do my friends need from me?”

You may find that it gives you more than you expected.

Frequently asked questions

Does giving produce happiness that lasts forever?

The reported experiments do not establish indefinite happiness. Happiness remained at its initial level across five days of spending on others, while a ten-round game showed a smaller decline when winnings benefited charity than when participants won for themselves.

What is prosocial spending?

Prosocial spending means spending money to benefit others. In the American survey described here, researchers grouped gifts for others and charitable donations into this category.

Does the research mean personal purchases cannot make people happy?

No. The article recognizes that personal purchases and enjoyable experiences can bring happiness. Personal spending was unrelated to happiness in the American survey, but that association does not establish that every personal purchase lacks emotional benefit.

Why might spending on others feel rewarding?

The article's central explanation is social connection. Spending on friends or partners can express affection and offer opportunities for positive self-presentation. These explanations should remain distinct from the reported findings of the two repetition experiments.