The Quiet Omen / Repeated Experiences

Why Cyberbullying Happens and How Its Cycle Repeats

Explore how personal judgments, social rewards and misleading content can sustain cyberbullying, and why checking facts matters before commenting.

Explore this hub Symbolic Life
An adult pauses beside a broken circle of coral spheres surrounding a solitary blue sphere.

Summary

Using Reset as its starting point, this article traces how judgments about character, supportive replies and fragmented accounts can turn online attacks into a recurring habit.

At a glance

Cyberbullying can become a repeating cycle when sensational fragments prompt personal attacks and supportive replies reward those attacks with recognition and belonging. Mental shortcuts can encourage judgments about character that overlook circumstances, while misleading content can provoke further abuse. Pausing before posting, examining the facts and taking responsibility for judgments can help interrupt this pattern without ruling out legitimate criticism of misconduct.

Beyond the Explosion: Cyberbullying’s Recurring Cycle

Episode 13 of the television drama Reset reveals the motive behind the bombing. The extreme actions of Guoyi and the bus driver are connected, in part, to the online abuse directed at Wang Mengmeng after the earlier incident. When she tries to force her way off the bus, commenters within the drama attack her with remarks such as “Has she gone crazy?” and “She’s out of her mind!” Others go further, asking whether her head is “full of shit” or declaring that someone like her deserves the eighteenth level of hell.

Words we would hesitate to say face to face can spill out online with little thought for the consequences. Watching Wang Mengmeng being bullied, viewers recognized the behavior immediately: “A true reflection of internet users today.” Yet when real viewers watched the surveillance footage of her visibly distressed behavior, some of them also posted extreme comments without stopping to think.

One commenter captured the contradiction: “One moment people are saying, ‘Don’t cyberbully.’ The next, they’re doing it themselves.”

How Common Cyberbullying Has Become

Someone can be lying in bed at home, browse a one-sided account of an event, and start hurling vicious abuse at a stranger as though that person were a sworn enemy. A few taps and a handful of comments are enough to take part. Cyberbullying means using online electronic communication to bully others. It takes various forms, including verbal attacks, spreading rumors and harassing people, doxxing, and exposing private information.

Statistics from outside China report that 24% of adolescents had experienced cyberbullying, while 17% said they had cyberbullied someone else. The verbal abuse shown in the drama’s scrolling on-screen comments is also a familiar sight on video platforms and in Weibo comment sections.

Offline, however, the “heroes” who so readily berate people as “crazy” online seem to disappear. Set aside an act as dangerous as grabbing a bus’s steering wheel and consider something more ordinary: someone dropping litter on the subway. The reported figures show that 90% considered the behavior wrong, yet 70% were unwilling to confront the offender because they feared retaliation. In everyday life, most people struggle to condemn wrongdoing directly to the person responsible.

The internet greatly reduces the anticipated cost of retaliation, making condemnation much easier. In a 2006 online survey jointly conducted by the China Youth Daily Social Survey Center and Tencent’s news center, 62.6% of respondents regarded a malicious desire to punish others as the foremost behavioral characteristic of an online mob.

Why Cyberbullying Happens

Speaking out against unethical conduct is not inherently wrong. Public opinion can sometimes help bring punishment for misconduct, as in the case involving Wu Moufan. I was angry, too, when I saw Wang Mengmeng grab the steering wheel: her actions threatened the lives of everyone on the bus. Condemning that behavior is a natural response. But something changes when criticism escalates into the insults appearing across the screen.

The shift happens when we automatically equate doing something wrong with being a bad person. Most of those on-screen comments went beyond condemning the act. They named Wang Mengmeng and attacked her personally—a living person reduced to a target.

As one on-screen comment pointed out, people were deliberately overlooking information to make a complicated situation seem simple. In their anger, they took mental shortcuts and readily assigned Wang Mengmeng motives such as willfulness and selfishness. This illustrates a common cognitive bias called fundamental attribution error, also known as the overattribution effect. When explaining someone else’s behavior or attitudes, we tend to place too much weight on internal qualities, such as personality and character, and too little on the circumstances surrounding them.

A debate offers a familiar example. Even when we know that speakers have been assigned the side they must defend, we can still assume that the arguments they present reflect their personal beliefs.

A classic experiment demonstrated the same bias. Participants read short essays supporting or opposing a policy, then inferred the writers’ own attitudes toward it. They knew that the writers had been assigned their positions. Even so, they tended to regard the authors of supportive essays as more personally supportive of the policy, and the authors of opposing essays as more personally opposed.

Part of the explanation is our preference for mental shortcuts. “They did that because that’s just the kind of person they are” takes little effort. Calling Wang Mengmeng “crazy” or “mentally ill” served the same purpose for many commenters: it spared them the work of considering her circumstances, looking for clues, or asking what she had actually experienced.

Moving from an observed action to a verdict on an entire person means passing judgment on something as complicated as human character. We know that complexity exists, yet we still make sweeping judgments with little sense of responsibility. Researchers have also found that requiring participants to explain their views—and thereby putting pressure on them to answer for what they said—significantly reduced the frequency of fundamental attribution error. This suggests that the bias can, to some extent, reflect a lack of accountability.

Moral condemnation based solely on intuition often comes with too little responsibility for the judgment being made. Once it loses its grounding in facts, it can turn into cyberbullying.

How Cyberbullying Becomes a Cycle

When attention settles on the most sensational fragment rather than the event as a whole, a harsh denunciation of the apparent wrongdoing can feel like the obvious response. That denunciation often attracts supportive replies, giving the person who posted it a sense of recognition and belonging. Those feelings act as rewards, encouraging similar comments the next time similar content appears. Gradually, casual attacks—and even cyberbullying—can become habits without people noticing.

At that point, an event may not actually make us feel angry, yet we can still express outrage almost automatically. It is rather like wanting a snack when we are not particularly hungry. Once someone begins participating in online abuse, the positive reinforcement of stimulus, response, and reward can draw them into a repeating cycle: an attack feels satisfying, and that satisfaction encourages another.

This cycle may also produce outrage fatigue, affecting how anger is felt and expressed in everyday life. Prolonged exposure to sensational, anger-provoking content can weaken the intensity of the anger people subjectively feel. Abusive venting, meanwhile, can generate more anger and may increase angry experiences later in daily life. These effects arise under different conditions: repeated exposure can dull the feeling, while lashing out can fuel it.

Independent media creators who distort or fabricate facts to attract attention also play an important part in the cycle. The mocking videos about Wang Mengmeng and Yutou Ge’s provocative commentary both serve the pursuit of attention and traffic. Selectively extracted video clips and accounts stripped of context can misrepresent what happened, whether intentionally or unintentionally. Sensational material is used to stir anger and invite a flood of abuse, generating large audiences that can be turned into substantial profits.

We seem to live in a post-truth era, with accounts of events repeatedly overturned as more emerges. When established news media fall silent and independent commentary proliferates, we sometimes learn about an event through someone like Yutou Ge confidently holding forth. As viewers of the drama, we have a fuller picture and can recognize that his account is false. In real life, without that privileged perspective, how often are we swayed by similar claims?

Breaking the Cycle

We seem drawn to moral judgments, repeatedly asking whether something is right or wrong. At the same time, our preference for easy answers leaves us vulnerable to cognitive biases and mistaken intuitive conclusions. The next time we are about to comment on a real person, we can pause before pressing send and recall a principle we learned as children: we are responsible for what we say.

Bertrand Russell’s advice to future generations offers a useful guide. Whatever we are studying or considering, he urged us to ask what the facts are and what they establish. We should resist being swayed by what we would prefer to believe, or by what we think would benefit society if people believed it. His counsel on wisdom was to keep our attention on what is actually true.

Before getting caught up in an argument over whether something is right or wrong, it can help to stop and ask a more basic question: did it actually happen the way we have been told?

Frequently asked questions

When can criticism turn into cyberbullying?

The article distinguishes criticism of misconduct from personal attacks that treat an action as proof of someone's entire character. Condemnation can become cyberbullying when it loses its grounding in facts and responsibility for the judgment.

How does fundamental attribution error relate to online abuse?

Fundamental attribution error involves placing too much weight on someone's character and too little on their circumstances when explaining behavior. In the article's drama example, commenters assign motives and labels instead of examining what Wang Mengmeng experienced.

Can online outrage both dull anger and increase it?

The article describes different conditions: repeated exposure to anger-provoking content can weaken subjectively felt anger, while abusive venting can generate more anger and may increase angry experiences later in daily life.