
Summary
A fresh start can encourage action without ensuring persistence. Explore how demanding goals, immediate costs, and optimistic planning complicate resolutions—and how smaller steps and present enjoyment may help.
At a glance
New Year’s resolutions can be hard to maintain because goals may be too ambitious, their benefits feel distant, and plans underestimate everyday obstacles. Difficulty following through does not depend entirely on self-discipline. Keeping the broader ambition while adding manageable first steps and positive experiences during action may help make persistence easier.
Why Do We Make New Year’s Resolutions—and Struggle to Keep Them?
Does this sound familiar? As one year ends and another begins, you enthusiastically make plans: keep a more regular sleep schedule, exercise more often, and study and work more efficiently. Yet within the first few weeks of putting those plans into practice, you often gradually set them aside and sometimes forget about them altogether.
What makes this puzzling is that the goals may seem perfectly reasonable. You thought them through, so why are they so difficult to maintain? When plans repeatedly break down, it is easy to blame a lack of discipline or willpower and overlook the broader psychological patterns involved. Research suggests that difficulty keeping New Year’s resolutions does not depend entirely on personal self-discipline. Much of it has to do with common features of how we think about time and turn intentions into action.
I. Why Are We So Eager to Make Plans at New Year?
New Year is more than a date on the calendar; it can also serve as a symbolic psychological boundary. At moments such as New Year, birthdays, or the beginning of a term, people are more inclined to look back, reassess their lives, and distinguish their imperfect past selves from who they are now. This mental separation can temporarily weaken the influence of past failures on current self-judgment, encouraging behavior that fits a new, more positive self-image (Peetz & Wilson, 2013).
These temporal landmarks can also bring the gap between our current circumstances and our ideal lives into sharper focus, motivating us to make changes. Dai, Milkman, and Riis (2014) found that people were more likely to begin exercising, dieting, or learning new skills around landmarks such as New Year. The researchers suggested that these moments interrupt our attention to everyday concerns and encourage a broader view of life, helping us focus on pursuing our goals. Making New Year’s resolutions is therefore more than a passing impulse: it reflects a common psychological response to the way time is structured.
II. Why Are Reasonable Plans So Hard to Maintain?
1. Goals Are Often Too Ambitious
New Year’s resolutions often promise a complete overhaul. You might plan to spend the year earning a qualification while completely changing your eating habits and learning a sport. Together, those commitments demand substantial effort. Clear, specific, challenging goals can help us develop our abilities, but there is a cost when the bar is set too high to reach. Höpfner and Keith (2021) found that failing to achieve excessively demanding goals can harm mood and self-esteem and reduce motivation. The more sweeping your resolutions, the more likely you may be to feel discouraged—or give up—when you fall short.
2. Rewards Are Distant, but Costs Are Immediate
It is easy to picture the benefits of a resolution: better health or a new skill. Achieving those benefits, however, takes accumulated time and effort, which can make them feel far away. Meanwhile, the costs are immediately tangible: feeling sleepy after getting up early, feeling tired after exercise, or losing time you would otherwise spend resting. That immediate discomfort can make the eventual benefits seem even more distant.
Research suggests that when rewards lie in the future but effort is required now, people are more likely to keep postponing action. This does not mean the plan is unimportant to them; immediate experiences often carry more weight in decisions (Steel, 2007). With the costs close at hand and the expected benefits far away, motivation can gradually fade. Simply blaming poor self-discipline misses our tendency to respond more strongly to what we experience now. Under these conditions, abandoning a plan is a common psychological outcome.
3. Expectations About Following Through Are Too Optimistic
We can also be overly optimistic about how carrying out a plan will unfold. You may believe that once you make a firm decision and get started seriously, you will be able to keep going, whether the aim is regular exercise, a new skill, or a change in everyday habits. In practice, obstacles often emerge along the way, gradually wearing down that initial confidence.
Psychologists explain this pattern in terms of the planning fallacy: when estimating how long a task will take or how difficult it will be, people tend to underestimate practical difficulties and interruptions while overestimating their ability to finish as planned. Research by Wiese, Buehler, and Griffin (2016) examined this bias and found that conventional planning—working forward from a starting point toward a future goal—can produce unrealistic estimates of completion time.
III. How Can We Approach New Year’s Resolutions More Realistically?
1. Break Plans Down into Actions That Are Easy to Begin
Start with concrete behaviors that are manageable and sustainable, rather than relying on a sweeping annual ambition alone. Rai et al. (2023), for example, found that dividing an annual volunteering target into weekly or fortnightly subgoals improved actual participation and persistence compared with setting only an annual target. The researchers suggested several possible explanations: smaller goals may strengthen people’s belief in their ability to act, reduce procrastination, and make progress easier to see.
You can apply the same approach when learning a sport. Keep the broader ambition—“I want to learn to swim this year”—and give it a concrete, measurable first step. That might be as simple as buying swimming equipment and getting into a pool for the first time.
2. Sustain Motivation with Immediate Feedback
Give yourself timely positive feedback when you complete a small goal. After following your plan for a week, for example, you might enjoy a favorite meal or set aside some time to relax. Research by Woolley and Fishbach (2016) found that, for long-term goals such as exercise and health behaviors, positive experiences during the activity supported persistence more than focusing only on the eventual, delayed rewards. The practical lesson is to make continued effort rewarding in the present. When each step brings some acknowledgment or enjoyment, rather than feeling like something to endure for a distant future, motivation becomes easier to sustain.
A More Realistic Starting Point
Difficulty keeping New Year’s resolutions cannot be reduced to a lack of effort. When we imagine the future, we tend to overestimate how feasible change will be. Rather than placing our hopes in a completely transformed future self, we may do better to design a starting point for the person we actually are—one that makes it easier both to begin and to keep going.
Frequently asked questions
Why does New Year make people want to set goals?
New Year can serve as a symbolic psychological boundary, encouraging reflection and temporarily weakening the influence of past failures on self-judgment. Such temporal landmarks can make people more likely to begin pursuing goals; they do not ensure long-term adherence.
Are challenging resolutions always a problem?
Clear, specific, challenging goals can help people develop their abilities. The concern is with excessively demanding goals: failing to attain them can harm mood and self-esteem and reduce motivation.
Does breaking a resolution into smaller steps mean abandoning the annual goal?
Keep the broader ambition while giving it a concrete, measurable first step. In the volunteering research described, weekly or fortnightly subgoals improved participation and persistence compared with an annual target alone; the suggested explanations were possibilities rather than established mechanisms.
How can immediate rewards help with long-term goals?
For long-term goals such as exercise and health behaviors, the research described found that positive experiences during the activity supported persistence more than focusing only on delayed rewards. The article suggests timely positive feedback and enjoyment as ways to make continued effort rewarding in the present.

