The Quiet Omen / Life Transitions

Irvin Yalom on Grief, Love and Life After Marilyn

A reflection on A Matter of Death and Life, Marilyn Yalom’s final days, and Irvin’s gradual return to meaning after profound grief.

Explore this hub Symbolic Life
An elderly man sits beside an empty armchair in a softly lit contemporary living room.

Summary

Marilyn faces the end of a fulfilled yet unfinished life; Irvin faces the unfamiliar task of living alone. Their shared book becomes a reflection on enduring love, painful separation and the slow return of meaning.

At a glance

In this reflection on A Matter of Death and Life, Irvin Yalom gradually finds renewed meaning through his children’s companionship, reading, writing, helping clients and the passage of time. His recovery follows overwhelming sorrow, numbness and difficulty accepting Marilyn’s absence; renewed meaning does not erase his grief. Marilyn’s account also explores how a sense of fulfillment can coexist with unfinished wishes, physical suffering and fear near death.

If you and your partner reached old age together, two people still dancing as life drew toward its close, which would you choose: to die first, or to be the one who remained?

I feel certain that Irvin Yalom would choose to remain. A leading figure in existential psychology who has helped countless bereaved clients, he knows what that choice can mean: deeper loneliness and pain that may last a year, three years, or longer. To stay is also to bear the grief.

Whenever Marilyn walked into a room, Irvin's heart would light up.

When Marilyn, the French literature professor and feminist pioneer he met at fifteen and had shared his life with for more than sixty years, became terminally ill, she proposed that they write a book together about their final days, titled A Matter of Death and Life. They began by taking turns, writing alternating chapters. After her death, Irvin continued alone and completed it.

I cannot quite describe what kind of book they made. I only know that, more than once while reading, I felt my heart tremble.

It concerns love, death, life and the meaning of existence, yet those large words barely contain its experience. Marilyn faces death with both helplessness and acceptance. Irvin resists the approaching loss, suffers overwhelming sorrow, passes through numbness and gradually begins to recover some vitality while learning to live alone. These are vivid, intimate versions of experiences each of us will encounter, once or perhaps several times.

Marilyn: A time to live, a time to die

Marilyn’s life was rich in love and purpose. She was a happy wife, loved throughout her life by a husband who never stopped admiring her radiance. She was a gentle mother who raised several children and remained loved and respected by them. She was also an accomplished woman in her own right, devoted to French literature and steadfast in speaking up for feminism.

Near the end, she arranged to see many friends. Many thanked her for the women’s mutual-support group through which she had helped change their lives. Their gratitude gave a concrete shape to what she had contributed. Hers had been a brilliant, generous life.

Marilyn herself recognized this. She felt that she had fulfilled her potential. There were still books she wanted to write and places she wanted to visit. There were things she regretted, including words that had hurt other people. But neither those regrets nor her unfinished plans could stand as the verdict on her entire life.

Some people believe that death opens onto another world, another adventure or another form of existence. Marilyn understood it differently. For her, death meant complete disappearance: consciousness ending, biological life falling silent.

Her acceptance did not spare her physical suffering. Eventually, she could not even walk from the doorway to the mailbox in the yard. Yet she deeply embraced Nietzsche’s idea of dying at the right time. In the larger reckoning of her life, she felt no regret. The more fully one has lived, the more readily one may accept the end.

What sustained her was an inward sense of fullness: satisfaction, meaning and value. She cared more about the depth and quality of life than its length. Having lived meaningfully, she wanted its final step to carry the same dignity.

Ultimately, Marilyn chose euthanasia. In her restrained writing, I sense fear and urgency alongside calm and composure. All belong to this courageous woman’s final expression of what it means to live. Her life had the brilliance of summer flowers; her death, the quiet beauty of autumn leaves.

Irvin: Even imagining life without her felt like betrayal

Irvin stayed beside Marilyn through the last part of her life. Holding her hand had always been the greatest joy of his life. He could never get enough of that closeness. It had delighted him when they were in junior high, and seventy years later it still did.

Now his eyes held tears he could barely contain, and he was overwhelmed by sorrow and anxiety. Imagining a future without Marilyn felt like a betrayal. Even allowing his attention to stray from her for a moment made him feel guilty.

After her death, he described her final moments in the book. Resting his head against hers, he concentrated entirely on her breathing, attentive to every slight movement. He silently counted her faint breaths. At fourteen, they stopped. He bent down and kissed her forehead. Her body was cold; death had arrived. He said goodbye to his Marilyn, his beloved Marilyn, forever.

In another farewell, he asked to see her once more. The people attending to her unzipped the bag to reveal her face. He leaned down and pressed his lips to her cheek. Her skin was cold and stiff. That cold kiss, he wrote, would remain with him for the rest of his life.

By this point, I was in tears. However old we become, however much we have experienced, a permanent goodbye can leave us helpless and desolate.

I deeply admire Irvin’s movement from resisting Marilyn’s death to respecting her decision about euthanasia. In my own society, quite apart from attitudes toward euthanasia and its abrupt final separation, even palliative care seems difficult for most relatives and friends to accept. They appear to see it as surrender to illness, a failure to take responsibility for life.

But does extending the time someone spends suffering necessarily give that person a richer or more beautiful experience of living? To me, what matters most is respecting each person’s wishes and their choice of the ending they find most acceptable.

Learning to live as a person in his own right

After Marilyn died, Irvin entered a long period of mourning. Its weight became visible in ordinary habits as much as in explicit expressions of sorrow.

He had never lived alone. In his younger years, there had been school roommates or companions in the military. Afterward, there had always been Marilyn. Now he was alone in the house they had shared, surrounded by reminders of her.

In a corner of the living room stood her portrait. Sometimes he turned it to face the wall because the sight of her eyes brought unbearable grief. Sometimes he turned it back. She was so beautiful. He dared not forget her, and he could not.

Whenever something interesting happened, his first impulse was still to tell Marilyn. It was almost as though an event could become real only once she knew about it. Only afterward would he recognize the irrationality of that impulse. His mind seemed to have mounted a defense too powerful to resist, continuing to insist that she was alive.

Knowing that someone has died does not necessarily make their absence feel real.

Nine weeks after her death, Irvin assessed himself as clearly depressed. He moved slowly, felt numb and dazed, and was frequently overcome by hopelessness. He had lost weight. Life offered little enjoyment, and being alone was difficult. In accepting his wife’s death, he felt that he had made little progress.

He continued working on the book every few days. Early in his bereavement, he also experienced an increase in sexual desire that left him ashamed and confused. After searching through many sources, he encountered an explanation that helped him understand it: when grief leaves people numb, sex can allow them to feel something. When confronting death becomes part of daily life, sexuality can itself affirm that one is alive.

His grief also brought him back to his own work. He reread the stories he had written about clients, revisited his experience of helping people through bereavement, and returned to the love for Marilyn expressed in his own sentences.

This brings to mind an image attributed to Schopenhauer: passionate love is a dazzling sun; when its brightness fades, the beautiful stars it once concealed become visible.

Yet this was no simple discovery of consolation. In old age, Marilyn’s death also meant losing many memories of their earlier life together. Irvin struggled between numbness and pain, repeatedly troubled by anxiety about his own death.

He improved slowly, helped by his children’s companionship, his continuing reading and writing, and the passage of time. Working with clients gave him a renewed sense of value. Through thought and experience, he continued trying to understand life itself.

A life that still matters

In his autobiography, Sartre describes quietly approaching his end. He imagines his final heartbeat inscribed on the last page of his work, leaving death with only a dead man to take.

I read this as a statement of fulfillment through creation. A life lasts only a few short decades, yet Sartre realized his value in his writing, through which later generations would remember him for centuries. In that sense, he could face death without regret.

For Marilyn, for Irvin, and for any of us, the underlying possibility is similar: to have lived fully and passionately, and to have left something behind, can be enough.

Eventually, Irvin could affirm that even though he could no longer share his life with Marilyn, even though he was alone, life remained meaningful and engaging. Life mattered.

That affirmation does not erase what came before it. His grief had been overwhelming, and recovery had taken time. Yet his life still had value beyond the relationship he had lost.

Whatever we lose, whoever we lose, however the loss happens and whatever feelings follow, we remain the central person in our own lives. Living well and experiencing life still matter. A great loss may feel as unbearable to us as Marilyn’s death did to Irvin. That suffering, too, becomes part of our experience of being alive.

Seek help and support. Let time help carry you through the hardest period, however difficult it is to keep going. Make room for the truth that separation belongs to life. Life matters.

I want to end where the book ends, with a passage attributed to the opening of Nabokov’s autobiography, Speak, Memory: the cradle rocks above an abyss, and common sense tells us that our existence is only a brief interval of light between two eternal darknesses.

Frequently asked questions

How did Irvin and Marilyn Yalom write A Matter of Death and Life?

Marilyn proposed writing about their final days together after becoming terminally ill. They wrote alternating chapters while she was alive, and Irvin continued alone after her death.

What helped Irvin Yalom after Marilyn’s death?

The article describes gradual improvement supported by his children’s companionship, continued reading and writing, the passage of time and a renewed sense of value through working with clients. This did not immediately remove his grief or anxiety about death.

Did Marilyn’s acceptance of death mean she had no regrets?

She still had books she wanted to write, places she wanted to visit and words she regretted saying. Her broader sense of fulfillment allowed her to see those regrets and unfinished wishes as parts of her life rather than its defining judgment. Acceptance also coexisted with physical suffering and emotions the reviewer reads as fear and urgency.