The Quiet Omen / Pattern Recognition

How Caffeine May Influence Impulse Buying

Explore how caffeine may influence impulse buying through energetic arousal, why product type matters, and how expectations could affect spending.

Explore this hub Psychology
Shopper holding coffee pauses before reaching for a candle in a minimalist homewares store.

Summary

A coffee before shopping may influence what catches your eye. Retail and laboratory findings connect caffeine with energetic arousal, spending and the appeal of pleasure-oriented products.

At a glance

Caffeine may increase spending through energetic arousal, particularly on pleasure-oriented products. The reported experiments found greater spending after caffeinated coffee, but sensitivity varies and drinking caffeine does not make everyone impulsive. Expectations about caffeine may also matter, while its overall balance of shopping enjoyment and spending effects remains unresolved.

Before you place that order, pause and put down your coffee, cola or tea. What could the drink in your hand have to do with the purchase you are about to make?

A group of French researchers explored that connection by setting up an espresso station outside a supermarket that mainly sold everyday necessities. Customers received either a free 50 mL coffee containing approximately 100 mg of caffeine or a 50 mL caffeine-free coffee. Those who received the caffeine-free drink did not know it contained no caffeine. After customers finished their drinks and shopped, the researchers collected their receipts. Customers who had consumed caffeine bought more items and spent more than those who had received caffeine-free coffee.

The pattern suggests a greater tendency toward impulse buying—a possible “caffeine effect” on spending. Yet before the experiment, most participants surveyed believed that drinking coffee had nothing to do with how much they spent while shopping. That contrast suggests an influence shoppers may not recognize.

Caffeinated drinks are popular around the world, from cola and tea to chocolate drinks and the many varieties of coffee. Caffeine occurs in varying amounts in some foods, especially beverages, making it a familiar part of everyday life. There is a reason some young people describe caffeinated drinks as what keeps them going: caffeine is a stimulant that can make the body feel more energized and alert.

Some studies have reported physiological arousal at intakes of 25–200 mg. Estimates of where that energizing effect is strongest differ, with some research putting it at approximately 200 mg and other research at around 100 mg. Excessive intake, however, may strain or even harm the body.

How feeling energized might affect spending

Neuroscience research offers one explanation for how caffeine might influence spending: it reportedly promotes dopamine release. In this account, higher dopamine levels reduce the availability of autoreceptors in the midbrain, a region involved in regulating behavioral motivation. That reduced availability weakens this regulation, potentially lowering self-control and increasing impulsive behavior.

Applied to shopping, the possibility is easy to picture. As you browse stores or an online shopping platform with a coffee, you may be more inclined than when shopping empty-handed to keep adding things to your cart: this one, another one, and then something else that catches your eye.

But would caffeine still increase impulsiveness if it produced no physiological arousal? Research reports individual differences in caffeine sensitivity and in how energized people become after consuming it. Drinking a caffeinated beverage does not mean everyone will behave impulsively. That variation leaves open the question of what happens when the energizing response is absent.

Biswas and colleagues examined the role of arousal in a second experiment, setting up a coffee station outside another chain retail store. Participants randomly received espresso containing 75 mg of caffeine, caffeine-free coffee or a 250 mL bottle of mineral water. The water comparison was intended to help address a possible placebo effect: believing they had consumed caffeine could itself increase participants’ physiological arousal.

After participants drank their assigned beverages and shopped, the researchers recorded shopping duration, spending and the total number of items purchased. Participants also completed two scales. One assessed mood, contrasting feelings such as being troubled or pleased. The other distinguished energetic arousal, ranging from tired to alert, from tense arousal, ranging from calm to tense.

Shopping duration was similar across the three groups, but participants who drank caffeinated coffee spent more than those in either comparison group. The researchers’ analysis linked this spending effect to energetic arousal, with neither tension nor pleasure explaining the increase. This suggests that reducing caffeine-related arousal could help reduce impulsiveness, in line with the proposed role of energetic arousal.

Why some products may become more tempting

The kinds of products on offer also matter. The proposed caffeine effect is more likely to appear with high-hedonic products: things that offer satisfaction and happiness but are usually nonessential, such as chocolate candy, popcorn, scented candles and massage devices. Ordinary notebooks or diaries and sticky notes illustrate the low-hedonic category.

Biswas and colleagues explored this distinction in a laboratory experiment. Participants received either a coffee drink containing approximately 100 mg of caffeine or a 500 mL bottle of mineral water. After drinking, they spent a few minutes doing something of their choice to give the caffeine time to begin taking effect. They then browsed a shopping webpage and selected items they wanted to buy from both product categories.

Participants who had consumed caffeine selected more high-hedonic items than those who had drunk water. For low-hedonic items, there was no statistically significant difference in the number selected. Participants selected items they wanted to buy; completed purchases were not reported.

One possible explanation for this product contrast is that impulses often seek pleasure. Research suggests that caffeine can encourage sensation-seeking and make people more sensitive to rewards. A separate line of research suggests that energetic arousal can heighten the perceived appeal of pleasure-oriented products, strengthening the intention to buy them. Imagine looking at a bag of chips when you feel highly energized: it might seem tastier and more tempting than it would when you feel calm. That illustrates how arousal could make a product’s promise of pleasure more compelling.

Could expecting caffeine also matter?

Could simply expecting caffeine influence your shopping, even without actually consuming any? It may be possible. In Biswas and colleagues’ retail experiment described earlier, customers who drank caffeine-free coffee spent more than those who drank water.

Research on caffeine expectations offers a possible explanation: anticipating caffeine can raise arousal through a placebo effect and may produce outcomes resembling those of actually consuming it.

If you make shopping decisions while strongly anticipating caffeine, some of those choices might be impulsive. Imagine spotting a coffee shop in a mall and preparing to go in for a cup. Even before you drink it, you might also feel a stronger desire to buy something from the other stores around you.

These possible influences do not settle whether caffeine makes shopping better or worse. Research also suggests that consuming moderate amounts of caffeine while shopping may make the experience more enjoyable. That possible benefit is distinct from the earlier retail finding that energetic arousal, rather than pleasure, explained the increase in spending.

The overall balance remains unresolved. What matters is keeping control over what we buy and finding genuine enjoyment in our purchases, rather than chasing a momentary thrill that leaves us regretting the whole shopping trip afterward.

If you are prone to impulse buying and it is causing problems in your life—perhaps you often regret what you buy—it may help to pause before placing your next impulsive order. Take a deep breath and consider whether you feel unusually excited or energized. Draw on past shopping experiences to think through how this purchase might affect your life and how you will feel about it later.

Biswas advises consumers who want to control impulsive behavior to try managing their caffeine intake, because its effects on purchasing may be unexpected. He offers that advice while maintaining that moderate caffeine intake benefits health.

And if staff at a store where you tend to buy impulsively warmly offer you a coffee and invite you in to browse, a little caution may be worthwhile. Stimulation could play a part in the choices you make next.