The Quiet Omen / Memory and Emotion

Thinking About Your Ex? How Nostalgia Affects Love

Remembering an ex can help or strain your current relationship. Explore how nostalgia, belonging needs, and personal growth shape the difference.

Explore this hub Psychology
Reflective adult sitting close to their current partner on a sofa in a softly lit modern living room.

Summary

Nostalgic memories and lingering attachment can play different roles in present relationships. The article explores belonging needs, positive models of intimacy, and the sense of growth that can emerge from remembering a former partner.

At a glance

Remembering good times with an ex alone does not establish whether someone has moved on. When belonging needs are unmet in a current relationship, longing for an ex can undermine it; when those needs are adequately met, nostalgic reflection may support satisfaction by highlighting positive lessons and personal growth. Excessive nostalgia can interfere with present relationships and moving forward.

Still Thinking of Your Ex? How Nostalgia Works in Romantic Relationships

At a class reunion, someone mentions that A has recently started dating B, prompting a conversation with C.

C: “Who do you think is the better partner—B or your ex?”

A: “B, of course. Things are going pretty well between us.”

C: “But you and your ex were together for a long time, weren't you? Have you thought about them since you broke up?”

A: “I can't say I never have. We did have some good times together.”

C: “Oh, so you're still hung up on them! I'm going to tell B.”

A: “That's not what I mean. Memories are just memories. B and I will make new happy memories together, too.”

So has A really moved on from their ex?

Remembering an Ex Can Reduce Emotional Investment in a Current Partner

People often take longing for an ex as a sign of dissatisfaction with a current partner. Research has also linked greater difficulty letting go of an ex with lower satisfaction in a current romantic relationship some time later, along with greater difficulty investing time and energy in that relationship.

One explanation comes from the belonging satiation hypothesis, which proposes that people have a fixed total need for belonging: once that need is met, they stop seeking additional belonging. Romantic relationships are one way of meeting it. Under this hypothesis, someone who still feels strongly attached to an ex and derives a substantial sense of belonging from that attachment may be less inclined to seek belonging from their current partner or work to maintain the relationship. The connection may also run in the other direction: greater dissatisfaction with a current relationship may strengthen emotional attachment to an ex. When the present relationship leaves belonging needs unmet, feelings may increasingly shift toward the former partner.

Some people quickly enter a new relationship to ease the pain of a breakup. Yet if, after the honeymoon period, they feel that their new partner is not ideal either, their feelings for their ex may grow stronger. The belonging substitution hypothesis offers a way to understand this possibility: close relationships can substitute for one another to some extent, so one relationship can partly compensate for the loss of another. When difficulties arise with a current partner, positive memories of an ex may help restore self-esteem and a sense of worth, potentially keeping feelings for the ex alive.

This makes attachment to an ex and the quality of a current relationship look like competing forces: as one grows stronger, the other weakens. But can experiences with a former partner also contribute something positive to a current relationship? They can.

Remembering an Ex Can Also Encourage Investment in a Current Partner

Researchers studying close relationships have found that former partners can play varied roles in people's current romantic lives, including positive ones. To investigate this possibility, researchers recruited people who had an ex and had been in their current romantic relationship for at least one month. Participants were randomly assigned to three conditions, each involving a different kind of memory-writing task.

  1. Nostalgic memories involving an ex. Nostalgia is a longing for people, events, or things from the past. It is a social emotion tied to the self, often involving close others or meaningful events—a moment when the past comes flooding back with feeling. Imagine entering a café and hearing a familiar song. After a moment, you recognize it as a song you and your ex both loved. You remember discussing it together and feeling closer as the conversation went back and forth.
  1. Ordinary memories involving an ex. These concern everyday events that are neither especially memorable nor emotionally intense. For example, you and your ex attended the same school. On a Friday when neither of you had classes, you went to the library together, each studying material for your own courses and occasionally taking a break to message the other.
  1. Ordinary memories unrelated to an ex. These concern routine experiences from your own life. For instance, one morning you got out of bed at 7, prepared a simple breakfast of one boiled ear of corn and one fried egg, then hurried out to catch a bus before 8 to get to work.

After writing, participants in all three groups rated how nostalgic they felt about their ex and the quality of their current relationship. Recalling nostalgic memories involving an ex improved satisfaction with the current relationship, regardless of who had initiated the breakup or whether the former partners were still friends. Neither ordinary memories involving an ex nor ordinary personal memories unrelated to an ex produced that benefit.

Nostalgia can bring a range of positive feelings, helping explain this result. But how do those feelings translate into benefits for a relationship?

1. Find Positive Models in Nostalgic Memories

Nostalgic memories can remind people that they are socially capable and valued by others, strengthening their sense of belonging and connection. These memories can make support from others feel more apparent while also encouraging people to offer whatever support they can in return. Nostalgia can also motivate positive social goals, such as maintaining a relationship or taking a more constructive approach to resolving conflict with a friend.

In romantic relationships, nostalgic memories of an ex can therefore serve as a resource. According to attachment theory, good memories can provide positive models for intimacy that people apply to their current relationships. Reflecting on a past relationship may help carry its positive lessons into the present. Remembering a time when you cuddled with an ex while watching a film and happily shared the experience, for example, might lead you to think: “I experienced closeness in a past relationship, so it is possible for me to experience that closeness in my current relationship, too.”

2. Recognize Personal Growth Through Nostalgic Memories

Positive models may not be the only way nostalgia helps a current relationship. Another possible pathway is the sense that we have grown as individuals.

In a second experiment, researchers used the same recruitment criteria—having an ex and having been in a current romantic relationship for at least one month—and randomly assigned participants to two groups. One group viewed two pages of screenshots from Dear Old Love, a website where people could write nostalgic recollections of former partners. The other viewed two pages of screenshots from Plans, a website for sharing everyday plans. Participants then wrote a short message they might post on their assigned website and rated their nostalgia for their ex, the quality of their current relationship, and their perceived personal growth.

Participants in the Dear Old Love condition rated their current relationship quality significantly higher than those in the Plans condition. The researchers also reported that increased feelings of personal growth mediated this improvement: the nostalgia task enhanced participants' sense of growth, which in turn contributed to more positive evaluations of their current relationship.

Because nostalgia centers on the self, it often includes themes of personal growth. People describing nostalgic memories commonly use words and phrases such as “change,” “moving forward,” and “the future.” Nostalgia can also help people recognize how they have grown, making them more willing to try new experiences and take actions that support further growth.

Nostalgic memories can also encourage a more positive view of the self, strengthening confidence, a sense of worth, and self-efficacy—here, the feeling that one is capable of handling the current relationship. One person's nostalgic recollection of an ex expressed this warmth: “When I think of someone long ago who recognized my worth and loved me wholeheartedly, I feel warm inside.”

Remembering an Ex Is a Double-Edged Experience

Remembering an ex can work in either direction, depending on whether belonging needs are being met in the present. When a current partner does not meet those needs, longing for an ex can harm the relationship. When a current partner adequately meets them, reflecting on the past can help someone recognize what they learned and gained from that earlier relationship, express love more effectively, and feel more satisfied with their current partner.

This is not a recommendation to spend your time longing for an ex. Excessive nostalgia can keep you absorbed in the past, interfere with your current relationship, and make it harder to move into a new life. But if a breakup has left you hurting, reflecting on the personal growth within nostalgic memories may offer a way to recover. Those memories can help you understand how the relationship changed you and use that understanding to build a good relationship with a new partner.

Frequently asked questions

Does remembering good times with an ex mean you have not moved on?

Remembering good times alone does not establish whether someone has moved on. The article distinguishes occasional recollection and nostalgic reflection from difficulty letting go of an ex.

Did ordinary memories of an ex improve current relationship satisfaction?

In the first experiment, ordinary memories involving an ex and ordinary personal memories unrelated to an ex did not produce the reported benefit. Nostalgic memories involving an ex improved participants' reported satisfaction, regardless of who initiated the breakup or whether the former partners remained friends. Participants had an ex and had been in their current relationship for at least one month.

Should you spend more time longing for an ex?

The article does not recommend spending your time longing for an ex. Excessive nostalgia can interfere with your current relationship and moving forward. If a breakup has left you hurting, reflecting on personal growth within nostalgic memories may offer a way to recover.