
Summary
A disappointing finale can reshape an entire story. Through entertainment examples and memory experiments, this article explores why peaks and endings linger—and why a deliberate farewell deserves care.
At a glance
The peak–end rule describes how memories of an experience are shaped by its most emotionally intense moment and its ending, while much of the intervening experience is overlooked. A peak can be positive or negative. The article’s cold-water example illustrates how a slightly less painful ending can improve remembered experience without removing earlier pain or reducing total discomfort.
How was your day?
Was it good enough to put on a song about good fortune and celebrate, or did it feel as though the universe had spectacularly turned against you?
That may be harder to settle than it sounds. People have many sides, with good and bad tangled together, and life rarely gives us an experience that is entirely pleasant or entirely painful.
Some things begin beautifully and gradually go wrong. Others barely attract our attention at first, then grow into something we admire. Yet when we look back, the ending can color everything that came before it.
When the ending changes the whole story
For many viewers, the Chinese sitcom iPartment was part of childhood. Its first series earned an 8.0 rating on Douban, the Chinese review platform. Its 2018 movie, however, received the tenth Golden Broom Award for Most Disappointing Film. Fans’ affection curdled into a bitter joke: their beloved “love apartment” had become a “love cemetery.”
Game of Thrones followed a similar trajectory. Once celebrated by viewers around the world as extraordinary television, it suffered a collapse in its reputation as it approached its conclusion. I remember being captivated by the cinematic images in the very first episode. Further into the series, I could only ease the discomfort of its increasingly flavorless plotting by watching at double speed.
Our impressions of people can change in much the same way. In China’s entertainment industry in 2021, one scandal followed another. Carefully cultivated images of fresh-faced stars fell apart, and some entertainment figures even ended up behind bars. Public perceptions of Li Yundi shifted from “prince of the piano” to a target of widespread criticism; Wang Leehom’s image shifted from exemplary idol to a partner condemned as manipulative; and Viya went from leading online influencer to tax evader. Like beautiful bubbles bursting, those glamorous images gave way to what audiences regarded as the faces behind the masks.
The movement can also go the other way. Xu Song, once mocked as one of “QQ Music’s Big Three,” later saw his musical talent carry a new album to leading positions across the charts. The previously little-known actor Zhang Xiaofei became the “nation’s mother” through Hi, Mom.
Whether we are judging a television series, a period of employment, or a romantic relationship, its ending influences our assessment of the entire experience.
Why peaks and endings carry so much weight
A good ending is half the battle. The peak–end rule offers an explanation for why.
In research conducted in 1993, psychologist Daniel Kahneman and his colleagues found that human memory rarely records events with complete accuracy. In the account offered by the peak–end rule, our memory of an experience is determined by two things: how we felt at its most emotionally intense moment, and how we felt at the end. Much of what happened in between is overlooked.
The peak and the ending are the “Moments of Truth,” or MOTs. Expressed as a formula:
Final emotional experience = (peak + end) / 2
In this account, the duration of the experience and the quality of its intervening moments have almost no influence on the memory we retain.
Consider the snacks Haidilao restaurant staff give customers as they leave, or the ice cream IKEA sells near its exit for 2 yuan. Both provide a pleasant final moment—a deft application of the peak–end rule.
A peak need not be a happy moment. It can be positive or negative, and negative experiences are remembered more clearly than positive ones.
When I think back to the days of China’s college entrance examinations, the questions and the material I studied have long since slipped toward the far end of the Ebbinghaus forgetting curve. But the anxiety of the mathematics exam, with sweat gathering in my palms, remains vivid. That younger version of me could still use a sympathetic hug.
So how might we use the peak–end rule to improve an experience?
A slightly better ending can transform a painful memory
The rule can lead us to make irrational choices. One experiment makes the puzzle especially clear.
Researchers had participants undergo two painful experiences of different lengths. In the shorter condition, participants immersed one hand in water at 14°C for 60 seconds. In the longer condition, they immersed the other hand in water at 14°C for 60 seconds, followed by another 30 seconds in water that had been warmed to 15°C.
The researchers then asked which experience participants would choose to repeat. The vast majority chose the longer one.
Were most of them gluttons for punishment? On a straightforward reckoning, 60 seconds of pain should be considerably preferable to 90 seconds: the longer condition included the same initial exposure, followed by additional discomfort.
But when participants looked back, the most painful moment and the pain they felt at the end played the decisive roles. In the longer condition, they were more likely to remember the slight easing of pain at the end and overlook the greater duration of the experience.
The conclusion drawn from this work is striking: adding a slightly less painful ending to a painful experience can make that experience more pleasant in memory. The extra time has not erased the earlier pain. It has changed the way the experience is remembered.
Why the latest impression lingers
Why does the ending matter so much? The recency effect offers an explanation. When we form an overall impression, newly acquired information can have more influence than information received earlier. When we recall the past, recent events become active in memory.
Psychologist Luchins illustrated this with two stories about a student named Jim. One portrayed him as warm and outgoing; the other described him as cold and introverted.
Group A first read the account of the warm, outgoing Jim. They then completed unrelated activities, including numerical checking tasks, before reading the account of the cold, introverted Jim.
Group B read the stories in the opposite order. They encountered the cold, introverted Jim first, completed unrelated activities such as numerical checking, and then read about the warm, outgoing Jim.
Finally, both groups were asked to describe his personality. The last story left the deeper impression in each group, and their descriptions reflected that final impression.
Similarly, once an experience is over, its ending can exert a powerful influence on how we judge everything that preceded it.
Give your goodbyes some care
If you intend to end a relationship, part with dignity.
If you have decided to leave your current job, allow yourself a little of that impulse to say, “The world is so big. I want to see it.”
For the sake of your own emotional experience, try saying a friendly goodbye to the person you used to be. Give the life you are leaving a deliberate farewell.
Quietly I leave, just as quietly as I came; I wave my sleeve, taking not a single cloud with me.
May our moments of farewell be as radiant as the clouds, leaving our memories of departure resting only on the beautiful moments.
Frequently asked questions
Does the peak in the peak-end rule have to be positive?
A peak need not be a happy moment. It is the most emotionally intense moment, and it can be positive or negative.
What happened in the cold-water experiment?
Participants experienced 60 seconds in water at 14°C and a longer condition with the same initial exposure followed by 30 seconds at 15°C. The vast majority chose to repeat the longer condition, whose ending was slightly less painful despite the additional discomfort.
Does a better ending erase earlier pain?
The extra time has not erased the earlier pain. A slightly less painful ending can improve how an experience is remembered while leaving the earlier pain and additional discomfort intact.
How does the article connect endings with the recency effect?
The article describes newer information as potentially having greater influence on an overall impression. In its Luchins example, participants read contrasting stories about Jim with unrelated activities between them; their final descriptions reflected the last story.
What does the article suggest about saying goodbye?
If you intend to end a relationship, it suggests parting with dignity. If you have decided to leave a job, it encourages allowing an exploratory impulse. It also recommends a friendly, deliberate farewell to your former self and life.


