The Quiet Omen / Meaning Making

Workplace Objectification: When People Become Tools

How repetitive work, unequal power and calculative thinking can encourage workplace objectification, and how people may internalize being tools.

Explore this hub Psychology
A worker pauses over identical wooden window frames beside a miniature house in a quiet modern workshop.

Summary

Does your work feel like assembling windows or building a whole house? That contrast opens a discussion of autonomy, replaceability and how being treated as a tool can shape the way people see themselves.

At a glance

Workplace objectification means treating people as usable tools while disregarding their autonomy and feelings. Repetitive, fragmented work, unequal power and calculative thinking can encourage it, sometimes without conscious intent. Recognizing this treatment may lead people to internalize it as workplace self-objectification; organizational changes and attention to inner experience may help resist that process.

Charlie is a worker from the last century whose job is to tighten hexagonal nuts. The work is repetitive and monotonous, but he keeps at it tirelessly, like a machine. When he cannot tighten the nuts fast enough, he chases the products along the conveyor until he is pulled into its outlet. Even after the production line stops, the tightening continues: his coworkers’ noses, a fire-hydrant tap, almost the buttons on a woman’s skirt.

“He’s gone mad!” the onlookers cry in horror. But seen through the instrumental logic of his workplace, even the subject of that sentence changes. Charlie is a walking wrench. It has gone mad.

Calling Charlie “it” reduces him to something useful, stripping away recognition of a unique person who can act and decide for himself. He has no say in his work. He occupies a small place on the production line and can be replaced at any time. No one cares how he feels. Even if he is injured, no one cares so long as the company’s interests remain unaffected. The person who tightens screws has become a screw in the machinery.

Psychologists call this way of treating someone workplace objectification. Objectification means treating another person as an object, and it can occur in any area of life. The psychological account of workplace objectification distinguishes two fundamental dimensions: instrumentality and denial of humanness. Instrumentality means seeing people as tools that can be exchanged, owned by others, or violated. Denial of humanness means failing to recognize their capacity to act autonomously, often while also ignoring their feelings.

You might think, “This has nothing to do with me. I respect everyone and never treat people as tools.” Yet workplace objectification can arise under particular conditions without our consciously choosing to see someone that way.

Consider a carpenter making a stool from start to finish alongside a production-line worker who does nothing but tighten nuts. Does the carpenter seem somehow “more human” to you? The question concerns our perception of the workers, not how much humanity either possesses. Research has found that people doing repetitive, fragmented work over which they have little control are more readily objectified by others.

Unequal power within a workplace can also encourage objectification. Research has found that people in positions of greater power are more likely to objectify their subordinates. A separate finding suggests that this tendency is stronger when those in power are unsure how to relate well to their employees and worry about that difficulty. Research on the other side of the hierarchy suggests that people with less power may also disregard their superiors’ humanity, seeing them merely as stepping stones to promotion and higher pay.

A focus on profit and goals can encourage us to evaluate people through their usefulness. The term calculative thinking describes weighing costs against benefits when making decisions, including decisions about other people. We might find ourselves thinking, “I could use this person for the project,” or “Socializing at work isn’t worth it if there’s so little to gain.” As we calculate what someone can offer us, concern for their humanity can slip out of view.

These conditions suggest that workplace objectification can arise automatically in a particular setting, without conscious intent or malice. We may find ourselves seeing Charlie as just another screw that keeps the production line running.

Seeing someone only in terms of what they can offer may even make approaching them feel easier. Starting a conversation can take courage; reducing your boss to a route to promotion might make that first move seem less daunting. But as we gaze into the abyss, it gazes back. We can also be the people reduced to tools—you and I included. It is hard to imagine a worker entirely untouched by workplace objectification. Have you noticed when it happens to you?

Organizational dehumanization describes the experience of recognizing that your organization sees you as a replaceable part rather than a unique person capable of making your own decisions. The distinction here is one of perspective: the organization sees the employee as a tool; the employee becomes aware of being seen that way.

Psychologists have linked this experience to greater physical and psychological discomfort, more slacking at work, and stronger intentions to leave. Pulling back from work or wanting to leave can also be understood as ways of pushing back against uncomfortable treatment. Seen that way, the response might not sound entirely bad.

But the harm does not end there. Research links awareness of being objectified at work to exhaustion and attempts to distance oneself psychologically from the job. Even when work takes up most of our week, we may still want to believe that the person we are at work is not our real self.

Yet if that working self is not really us, who is it? A tool being used—and we may begin to accommodate that expectation, accepting that our role is to be useful and treating ourselves accordingly.

This is workplace self-objectification. Others treating us as tools, our recognizing that treatment, and our beginning to treat ourselves as tools are three distinct experiences. Awareness of someone else’s instrumental view of us can give way to taking that view into our own sense of who we are.

One experiment illustrates how the organization of a task can shape that sense of self. Two groups of students spent 20 minutes on different craft activities. One group assembled windows for a small wooden house. Each window had to be completed within a short, fixed interval. Finishing early earned no break: students had to start the next window immediately. The other group built an entire small wooden house themselves, with no timing reminders during the 20-minute activity. The researchers reported that students who assembled windows under these constraints felt more like tools and less like people than those who built the whole house.

Does your own work feel closer to assembling windows or building a whole house?

One way to understand the contrast is through the room each task leaves for creativity, understanding, and control. Building the whole house allows us to create under our own direction, understand the task as a whole, and take charge of completing it. Assembling windows means repeating a task that calls for less skill or creativity. The work is fragmented, leaving us without a full understanding of the construction process. Other people and performance demands set the pace, making it difficult to work at our own rhythm and undermining our ability to plan for ourselves.

Work organized this way can encourage us to accept being tools. Research links workplace self-objectification to lower engagement in tasks and poorer performance. The attitude might be: why make an effort if I am only a tool anyway?

The research-linked account also suggests that the consequences may follow us beyond work. We may internalize the passivity of the job, continuing to rely on outside forces to make choices for us and becoming more inclined to go along with other people’s views. Charlie offers an image of that persistence: even outside the factory, he keeps tightening things like a wrench, rather than freely deciding how to engage with life.

What can we do if we leave the work of tightening screws but still carry the habit of being a screw ourselves? Nobody should have to be a tool.

Psychologists have proposed several ways to address workplace self-objectification, most of them directed at organizational management. Their recommendations include improving relationships among employees and supporting an atmosphere where colleagues can express themselves. Leaders should value employees’ autonomy and recognize them as capable people. Organizations should also create a good working environment that takes each person’s needs seriously. These are some of the recommendations, rather than an exhaustive list.

For individuals, I find another finding more directly relevant: research suggests that high private self-consciousness can prevent people from internalizing others’ objectifying perceptions of them. Private self-consciousness means noticing and examining our inner experience and feelings. Paying closer attention to ourselves can help us move beyond passively accepting other people’s expectations and lessen the negative effects of workplace self-objectification.

Perhaps we have never fully escaped workplace objectification. Our choice of jobs is limited. At work, we may use other people as tools, deliberately or without realizing it, then recognize our own place as a screw in a much larger machine. As the machine keeps running, we may come to accept that place, absorbing its view of us into our own sense of who we are. Recognizing this process gives us a chance to keep caring for ourselves and others, to stay alert to how we treat people and continue questioning how we are treated.

People who tighten screws should not themselves be reduced to screws. I should not be. You should not be. Neither should Charlie, nor anyone else.

In Kant’s terms, human beings are ends in themselves, rather than merely means to someone else’s purposes.

Frequently asked questions

Can workplace objectification happen without conscious intent?

Workplace objectification can arise automatically under particular conditions, without conscious intent or malice. Repetitive, fragmented work with little control, unequal power and calculative thinking can encourage it.

What does private self-consciousness mean in this context?

Private self-consciousness means noticing and examining inner experience and feelings. Research suggests that high private self-consciousness can help prevent people from internalizing others’ objectifying perceptions of them.