
Summary
Fictional villains can fascinate through self-relevance, skill, complexity and artistic distance without requiring approval of harm.
At a glance
Liking a fictional villain can reflect curiosity, identification or admiration for performance and competence. These reactions differ from endorsing wrongdoing, though fiction does not guarantee a uniform moral response.
The Bad Girls in The Bad Guys 2 make an energetic entrance into a familiar tradition: antagonists who command attention as readily as the heroes. Kitty Kat, Pigtail and Doom combine force, intelligence and deception in a way that makes them entertaining to watch. Their appeal raises a question that extends well beyond animated heists.
Why can we find a character fascinating while rejecting almost everything they do?
Hannibal Lecter in The Silence of the Lambs and the Joker in The Dark Knight are obvious examples. Chinese television offers others, including Gao Qiqiang in The Knockout and An Lingrong in Empresses in the Palace. These characters differ substantially, so no single explanation should be expected to account for every viewer's interest. Several overlapping ideas help make sense of the attraction.
Exploring a less familiar part of yourself
Carl Jung's idea of the shadow offers one interpretive lens. It concerns aspects of ourselves that we find difficult to acknowledge or reconcile with our preferred identity. Aggression, envy, a desire for power, or the wish to disregard expectations may be uncomfortable to recognize. The shadow is not simply a hidden criminal self, and enjoying a villain does not reveal a secret wish to imitate their crimes.
A story can give a forbidden possibility a vivid form. A character acts without restraint, refuses to be agreeable, or pursues an ambition with a freedom the audience would not accept in ordinary life. We can become curious about that possibility while still believing the character's conduct is wrong.
This may also expose the effort involved in maintaining an acceptable public self. Parts of ourselves that remain unexpressed can feel intriguing when a fictional person displays them openly. That is a possible reading of an experience, not a psychological test hidden inside your favorite film.
Research offers a more specific account of self-relevance. In Can Bad Be Good?, Rebecca Krause and Derek Rucker investigated whether people could be attracted to negatively viewed others who resembled them when comparison felt less threatening. Their 2020 paper appeared in Psychological Science.
The researchers analyzed a company's character-preference data and conducted five laboratory experiments involving 1,685 participants. Their findings supported the idea that similarity can encourage attraction to negative characters when threats to one's self-image are reduced. Fiction can provide a setting in which such comparisons feel safer.
The finding is narrower than proof that villains release repressed impulses. It suggests that recognizing something of ourselves in a villain need not always repel us. A story may let us consider the resemblance without treating it as a declaration of our own moral identity.
The experience can resemble a roller coaster: the fear and excitement feel real, while the setting changes what the danger means. Enjoying an intense story can offer emotional release, but the metaphor does not establish that watching aggression purges aggressive impulses or improves behavior afterward.
Admiring ability while judging conduct
Villains often receive some of the most memorable writing, performances and visual presentation in a story. Their attraction may lie in a combination of exceptional skill, complicated motives, confidence and a distinctive code. Sometimes the fascination comes from trying to understand a person whose choices remain deeply objectionable.
Hannibal's cultivated knowledge and taste sit beside his brutality. Thanos's determination and ability to execute a plan can be striking even while his goals are horrifying. The Joker's theatrical unpredictability gives scenes an unsettling energy. Darth Vader's commanding presence can hold attention without making his violence acceptable.
It helps to distinguish several reactions. Finding a performance compelling, understanding a character's motives, admiring their intelligence and agreeing with their choices are different judgments. You can experience one without experiencing the others.
The concept of moral decoupling describes a related separation between judgments of performance and judgments of morality. In research by Amit Bhattacharjee, Jonathan Berman and Americus Reed II, people could support a public figure's performance while condemning that person's misconduct. This differed from rationalizing the conduct as less wrong.
Applied to fiction, the distinction might sound like this: the character is a fascinating strategist, and the harm they cause remains wrong. This is a useful analogy from research on public figures, rather than a demonstrated automatic process in every viewer of villain-centered entertainment.
It also differs from moral disengagement, associated with Albert Bandura's work, which concerns ways of making harmful conduct seem acceptable or avoiding self-condemnation. Separating skill from morality does not require excusing victims' suffering. Keeping that difference visible makes appreciation more precise.
What the screen changes—and what it cannot guarantee
Fiction gives us control and distance. We can watch, pause, stop, discuss the scene, or return to familiar fictional worlds. A threatening character is not physically present in our room. Knowing that can allow curiosity, suspense and empathy to coexist with moral disapproval.
Art also directs attention. Music, framing, costume, dialogue and the choice of whose pain receives screen time influence how a scene feels. The violent sequences in The Pig, the Snake and the Pigeon, for example, invite attention to composition and sound as well as action. Their aesthetic form is part of the experience; it should not erase the violence being represented.
The yandere archetype in anime and related media makes the distinction particularly sharp. Extreme possessiveness, stalking or confinement may be stylized as dramatic devotion. Enjoying a fictional trope does not turn those acts into acceptable conduct in a real relationship. In reality, another person's autonomy and safety remain central, however intense the claimed love.
Still, the screen is not a guarantee that everyone interprets a story alike. Some narratives condemn their villains explicitly; others leave wrongdoing unpunished or deliberately unsettle the viewer's judgment. There is no automatic moral reset at the ending. We can enjoy the craft while asking whose perspective is missing and what the story makes easy to overlook.
Let curiosity become a clearer question
A favorite villain is not a verdict on your character. Instead of asking only whether it is bad to like them, ask what holds your attention. Is it the intelligence, audacity, vulnerability, performance, visual style, resemblance to yourself, or the freedom to imagine an unfamiliar possibility?
Those answers can be interesting without becoming a diagnosis. The value of the experience lies in being able to remain curious and discriminating at the same time: to understand why a character fascinates you while keeping your judgment about their actions intact.
Frequently asked questions
Does liking a villain make me bad?
A character preference alone is not a moral diagnosis.
Does Jung’s shadow explain every villain preference?
No. It is one interpretive lens, not a proven universal mechanism.
What is moral decoupling?
It separates judgments of performance from judgments of morality, without necessarily excusing misconduct.
Why does fiction feel safer?
Distance and control can make exploration possible, though viewers and narratives differ.


