
Summary
A setback can offer useful information while making that information painful to face. Learning from others and pursuing attainable goals may help restore a sense of possibility.
At a glance
Repeated failure does not automatically produce learning or success. In experiments reported by Eskreis-Winkler and Fishbach, failure feedback was associated with poorer learning; they proposed that threats to self-esteem can make people disengage from useful information. The writer recommends learning from others, separating setbacks from personal worth, and creating small, attainable successes to help renew confidence.
“Failure is the mother of success.” The writer recalls hearing this saying since childhood, widely accepted as a truth about how life works. Repeated setbacks, though, can make that promise difficult to believe.
Consider a student whose disappointing grades show no improvement the following semester, or someone who fails a postgraduate entrance examination, tries again, and fails a second time. A job seeker approaches three employers without receiving an offer, then gets the same result from a fourth and a fifth. When another attempt still brings no breakthrough, does failure really lead to success simply because it comes first?
Eskreis-Winkler and Fishbach investigated what people learn from success and failure feedback. In their experiments, participants learned less after being told they were wrong than after being told they were right.
The researchers recruited participants online and randomly assigned them to two groups. Participants encountered unfamiliar symbols created by the researchers, with no fixed meanings, and answered questions such as, “Which of these two symbols represents an animal?” Having never seen the symbols before, they could only guess. One group was told that every answer was correct; the other was told that every answer was incorrect. Either kind of feedback provided information from which participants could learn the symbols’ meanings: with only two options, being told a choice was wrong also pointed to the alternative.
After completing a distraction task, participants answered the earlier multiple-choice questions again. Those who had received failure feedback showed poorer learning.
That result left another possibility open. Perhaps success feedback helped people learn, while failure feedback left learning intact. To examine this, the researchers added a group that received no feedback and compared its performance with that of the failure-feedback group. Because participants given no feedback had never been told whether their answers were correct, this comparison measured recall of earlier choices rather than knowledge of the correct symbol meanings. The failure-feedback group again performed worse. This suggested that failure feedback could impair recall, beyond any learning advantage supplied by success feedback.
Why might information about a mistake be harder to retain? Eskreis-Winkler and Fishbach proposed that failure threatens the ego: a blow to self-esteem may lead people to turn away from information about their mistakes, leaving them less able to learn from it.
In a further experiment, participants rated how much the task had hurt their self-esteem. Those who received failure feedback performed worse and reported greater injury to their self-esteem. The researchers also reported an indirect effect on learning through this self-reported injury, consistent with their proposed explanation.
For the writer, these findings invite a reversal of the familiar saying: “Success is the mother of success.” Success can foster further success, while wounded self-esteem can make the information a failure offers difficult to face. A setback may contain something useful to learn, yet attending to it can be painful enough that people disengage.
Does that make the inherited promise about failure an illusion—or even a lie? The writer resists dismissing it altogether. Failure can help, the argument goes, but its benefits depend on conditions.
Major failures, the writer suggests, can often teach lessons that help prevent the same mistake from happening again. Separately cited research reports that people respond more strongly to negative than positive events physiologically, cognitively, and emotionally. Drawing on that claim, the writer reasons that a sufficiently striking failure may command attention, making both the painful experience and the information it offers harder to ignore.
Yet even a serious problem can remain unnoticed. Consider two people in an intimate relationship who may have grown emotionally distant long before either recognizes what is happening. Feelings are less visible than examination scores, so their gradual estrangement can be hard to detect. Only when the relationship ends might they realize how early the trouble began. While that deterioration remains unrecognized, there is little opportunity to learn from it.
This does not mean a failure must be enormous before someone can learn from it or move toward success. Eskreis-Winkler and Fishbach’s follow-up experiments explored another possibility: whether failure becomes easier to learn from when examining it no longer threatens a person’s sense of self-worth.
They used observational learning, also called vicarious learning. Participants watched other people answer questions and saw whether those answers were correct. The researchers reported that this removed the threat to the observers’ self-esteem and improved their learning from failure in the experiment.
The writer draws a practical recommendation from this finding: separate a failed experience from your sense of who you are. Look at how people with experiences similar to yours responded to their setbacks, and learn from their stories. When considering your own failure, try interpreting it without treating it as proof that you lack ability. A reminder such as “Failing at this does not mean I am incapable; I still have abilities worth recognizing” expresses the kind of reassessment the writer recommends.
A second recommendation is to create opportunities for success by breaking a large goal into smaller, attainable ones. Research cited in support of this approach links small successes with greater self-efficacy—the belief that you can carry out what you set out to do.
Take the goal of earning good grades. The writer breaks it down into classroom participation, individual assignments, group assignments, preparation for finals, and the final examination, working toward each in turn. In this example, speaking up in class earns points toward the grade, so each contribution is a small success that counts toward the larger aim. As those successes accumulate, the overall goal can begin to feel more attainable.
Even a single success may matter after repeated setbacks. Research reports that one success can strengthen people’s conviction that they will eventually succeed, improve how they feel, and help them persist. A separate research report suggests that people see a success as an accurate reflection of their real ability. Another finding concerns their belief that others see them as sufficiently intelligent.
The writer connects these favorable self-evaluations with renewed confidence in succeeding again. For someone who has faced several failures in a row, the recommendation is to choose a simple, achievable goal. One success may open a way forward, helping possibilities come into view again.
The writer wishes readers well in life, study, and work, and recommends learning from others or creating opportunities for small successes when setbacks arise. The practical priority is to affirm yourself and protect your self-esteem.
There is also a question the writer sometimes returns to: what counts as failure? For one person, passing an examination is a success; for another, anything below ninety is a failure. The same result can carry either label, depending on the standard used to judge it.
We often hold ourselves to demanding standards. If you look back carefully at the steps you have already taken, you may find something those judgments have overlooked: a little progress, or a little more achieved today than yesterday.
Frequently asked questions
What is observational learning in the failure-feedback experiments?
Participants watched other people answer questions and saw whether those answers were correct. The researchers reported that this removed the threat to the observers’ self-esteem and improved their learning from failure in the experiment.
Can one small success help after repeated setbacks?
Research reported in the article suggests that one success can strengthen belief in eventual success, improve feelings, and support persistence. The writer therefore recommends choosing a simple, achievable goal after repeated failures; this encouragement does not establish that the larger goal will be achieved.


