
Summary
The armor that eases emotional pain can also complicate closeness. A discussion of Why Do I Do That? examines three defenses and the imperfect work of understanding them.
At a glance
In this discussion of Why Do I Do That?, psychological defenses are presented as largely unconscious ways of avoiding painful or unacceptable feelings. Displacement, reaction formation and projection illustrate how immediate protection can carry lasting costs for self-understanding and relationships. The writer advocates recognizing these responses and accepting a wider emotional life, describing change as an ongoing, imperfect process.
In King Lear, Act 1, Scene 1, a man is described as never having understood his own changeable emotions. The observation raises a question that also runs through the subject of psychological defense: Why do I do that?
Perhaps you recognize some of these experiences. You eagerly anticipate a vacation, only to feel bereft when it ends. Frustrations at work spill over into anger at the people around you. The grapes you cannot reach become, in your telling, sour, bitter, spicy, or salty. Or you cannot resist showing yourself off, like a peacock spreading its feathers, longing for other people's envy and admiration.
The list could go on. Recognizing a reaction in yourself does not necessarily mean understanding why it happens.
You may already be familiar with Freud. His psychoanalytic tradition has been criticized for its weak scientific foundations and circular reasoning. The writer discussing Why Do I Do That? nevertheless regards newer psychoanalytic approaches as having matured into an important branch of counseling, and proposes psychological defense as an explanation for these puzzling reactions.
A defense is like armor we put on without noticing. Why Do I Do That? defines psychological defenses as the lies we tell ourselves to avoid pain. The writer expands on that definition: when a thought or feeling is too painful, or feels morally unacceptable, we may automatically turn away from it and push it into the unconscious. Deceiving ourselves feels easier than facing the truth. Usually, we do not recognize that this is happening; we can suffer under the very mechanism that is protecting us.
The writer identifies three common situations in which defenses come into play. One is coping with a need that feels ill-timed or unacceptable, illustrated by someone who has quit smoking and dislikes seeing other people smoke. Another is enduring intense emotion: a breastfeeding mother may resent her baby's noise but direct her hostility toward the baby's father. A third is the wish to feel worthy and respected. Someone who feels insecure may present themselves as proud or arrogant in an attempt to gain that respect.
The difficulty with this protection, in the writer's account, is its time horizon. Defenses attend to relief here and now, without considering tomorrow. An unthinking response that eases pain in the moment can carry a lasting cost.
The wish to feel only happiness creates a related difficulty. When other emotions bring discomfort or pain, we may dismiss them as “bad,” as though they have no right to exist. The author of Why Do I Do That? poses a question in response: do you want to understand what you actually feel, or do you want to have only one feeling?
Emotions, the writer reminds us, are temporary experiences; they come and go. Invoking a saying attributed to Jung that conscious awareness does not come without pain, the writer argues that working through our defenses requires accepting the full range of our experience, including the feelings we would rather avoid.
Learning to recognize defenses gives us a starting point. The writer describes their use as widespread and introduces a few of the mechanisms discussed in the book, with a playful warning: they may take a second look, a third, and perhaps a few more before they begin to make sense.
Displacement
When something inhibits us from expressing a feeling, desire, or attitude directly toward its original target, displacement redirects it toward a safer or more socially acceptable one. That shift provides an outlet and reduces anxiety.
Consider the writer's illustration. A man is scolded by his superior and comes home upset. He finds a pretext to berate his wife. Distressed by a scolding she cannot account for, she hears their child making noise nearby and slaps him. Their son walks away furious at having been struck without cause. When the family dog approaches him, he kicks it.
The anger passes from one target to another: feelings that cannot be expressed toward the person who prompted them find an outlet elsewhere.
Reaction Formation
A feeling can also be concealed by outwardly expressing its opposite. In reaction formation, an inappropriate desire or motive is repressed into the unconscious while behavior displays the reverse.
Someone trying to quit smoking, for instance, may still crave cigarettes yet make exaggerated declarations about the disastrous fate awaiting anyone who smokes: “Smokers are bound to come to a bad end.” In the writer's illustration, this condemnation helps the person reassure themselves that abstaining is the right choice.
Projection
Projection means attributing our own guilty thoughts, bad habits, or unacceptable traits, attitudes, ideas, and desires to someone else, then condemning or criticizing that person for them.
Put this way, projection can sound entirely malicious: an irrational attack or an attempt to evade responsibility. The writer, however, describes it as a normal phenomenon originating in everyone's infancy. In this account, a baby who cannot communicate what they need cries out in distress. The parents “absorb” that feeling, become uncomfortable themselves, and respond by feeding the baby or changing a diaper. The baby's distress subsides. The writer interprets this exchange as projection at work.
This explanation presents projection as a search for an empathic response that offers relief from distress. Suppose someone points out a mistake you have made. You feel guilty, but turn on the other person, accusing them of being harsh and judgmental. In the writer's interpretation, you pass your guilt and uneasy conscience to that person, escaping those feelings yourself.
Other people may also project their distress onto you. If you feel attacked and retaliate by sending those same painful feelings back, the exchange can become a “war of projection,” escalating as each person returns the other's distress.
The writer recommends recognizing when projection may be happening and recalling the image of a crying infant who needs attention. The analogy encourages an attempt to understand and comfort the other person, helping them bear their distress and find relief. This can be an unwelcome responsibility. Still, the writer sees helping to bear a loved one's emotions as part of caring for them.
That responsibility runs both ways. It also means noticing when you are projecting and making an effort to reduce the emotional burdens you pass to the people close to you.
Taking Off the Protective Shell
The writer describes the cover of Why Do I Do That? as a sheep hidden inside a hedgehog's shell, interpreting the image as a painful consequence of self-protection: the shell that shields us can also wound the people who approach to care for or protect us. The invitation is to take off that shell and look inward.
In this account, defenses work invisibly when we encounter aspects of ourselves we find intolerable, keeping unacceptable thoughts and feelings outside our awareness. Their effects reach beyond what we fail to see in ourselves: they often distort our perception of reality, including how we understand our relationships and our own emotions.
The writer urges us to tolerate our needs, experience the varied emotions that give life meaning, and feel content with who we are. Working through defenses is a long, winding process, perhaps one that never ends. No one manages it perfectly. Still, the effort can help us live with our defenses without being ruled or constrained by them. What matters most, the writer emphasizes, is the courage to step beyond familiar safety and make a change.
A concluding passage from Why Do I Do That? offers this perspective: nothing in the psyche can simply be eliminated, but we can keep growing and develop other aspects of ourselves to compensate for our difficulties. The passage also claims that reflection and effort can establish new neural connections capable of offsetting, to some degree, harm that has already occurred.


