
Summary
A Christmas conversation at a care home exposes the gap between assuming someone’s wishes and hearing them. The essay connects that gap with a larger inquiry into the mind, experience and suspended judgment.
At a glance
The essay suggests that understanding the mind may emerge through suspending assumptions, attending to changing experience, and carefully asking and listening. Its care-home example shows how confidence about another person’s wishes can replace necessary inquiry. Perhaps there is no predetermined perfect answer to the mind’s nature; understanding may develop through repeated encounters.
How might we answer a question such as “What is the nature of the mind?” An essay on a book introducing existential psychology approaches it through an image of human existence that resists a settled definition. In its opening epigraph, drawn from another philosophical work, that work’s author describes human beings as creatures of distance: always beyond themselves, their existence open toward the future at every moment.
The difficulty of finding a settled account becomes apparent even in physics. In his introduction to loop quantum gravity, theoretical physicist Carlo Rovelli imagines a student attending a general relativity class in the morning and a quantum mechanics class in the afternoon. The student might suspect that these foolish professors had not spoken to one another for at least a century. How else could the morning’s world of curved, continuous spacetime become the afternoon’s flat space of discontinuous quantum interactions?
The essay’s writer suggests that Rovelli can count himself lucky he is not a psychologist: the bewilderment would only multiply. In the writer’s pointed comparison, humans in the accounts of two drive-focused psychoanalysts are merely higher animals driven by incestuous fantasies. Turn to three theorists emphasizing interpersonal attachment, and humans seem suddenly to have grasped the mysteries of interpersonal relationships without instruction, clinging tightly to one another. Then comes the ingenious personality researcher, who sidesteps the psychoanalytic quarrels altogether: use statistics to identify five basic personality traits, measure someone’s scores on each, and there is your account of what kind of person they are. Yet these traits seem disconnected from both the incestuous fantasies and the interpersonal relationships of the preceding explanations.
If a thousand readers find a thousand different Hamlets, the writer jokes, a thousand psychologists might offer two thousand answers about the nature of human behavior. Even a single psychologist’s early and later views can contradict one another.
For the writer, this disagreement raises a question beyond the rivalry among theories. The more precisely and objectively we try to study the mind’s essence, the more bewildered we may become about why human beings exist. With scissors, essence and purpose seem straightforward: two crossed cutting blades make a tool for cutting. A teacup is a vessel that holds hot water for brewing tea. But human nature is much harder to pin down, leaving human purpose murkier still.
In a work on the crisis of European science and transcendental phenomenology, its author gives this uncertainty a conditional form. If history teaches us only that all spiritual creations, all the conditions of life people depend on, their ideals and norms, arise and disappear like passing waves; if reason always turns into absurdity and good deeds into disaster, in the future as in the past—can the world, and human existence within it, really have meaning?
The writer connects confusion about life’s meaning, and the denial of it, with the emergence of antinatalism, presented here as the view that humanity should immediately cease all reproduction and move toward extinction. Peter Zapffe, named as a representative of this view, compares bringing a baby into the world to carrying wood into a burning house.
Faced with these difficult questions, the philosopher who posed that question about meaning turns, in the writer’s account, to epoché, or suspension: setting aside abstract assumptions and emotional associations that might interfere with studying the mind. The writer traces the practice to an ancient Greek skeptic. To suspend something is to leave it outside the discussion temporarily, with the possibility of returning to it later. It means postponing judgment so that preconceptions do not distort what we are trying to understand.
The examples offered range from academic disciplines to everyday pleasures. Logic brackets its content; mathematics, its concrete or pictorial objects; biology, physics. Literature sets aside paper and ink, just as film sets aside the screen. Appreciating food can mean leaving its nutritional composition out of consideration; romantic love can bracket reproduction. In these analogies, bracketing directs attention. The matters set aside need not be denied in order to be left, for the moment, outside the inquiry.
The writer then draws a distinction. Earlier uses of suspension set something aside so that the mind could study it. The philosopher extends the gesture to the mind itself, bracketing it too and making it an object of observation and experiential attention.
What, then, is the writer’s own mind like at this very moment? The chair feels comfortable; the lamplight is gentle. But there is a manuscript in front of them, overdue and needing to be finished soon. Worry about an application result returns, prompting another check of the inbox. Their eyebrows itch, so they scratch them. Then a sudden sound comes from the kitchen floor. For now, they are willing to believe it is not a ghost—but perhaps it would be best to hurry off to sleep.
Which of these experiences touches the mind’s essence, and which does not? The writer finds it difficult to say; dismissing any one of them would be presumptuous. From this perspective, the mind ceases to look like a set of rigid rules or a machine that operates without exception. It appears instead as phenomena continually emerging and changing within the flow of consciousness.
Sarah Bakewell gives this view a striking formulation: understood in this way, the mind is almost nothing in itself; it consists of the characteristics of everything related to it. In her account, this alone sets the mind apart from every other naturally occurring entity.
The writer sees the close relationship between mind and activity as increasingly common ground among psychologists and philosophers. In a work on the philosophy of psychology, another philosopher describes the mind as anything but idle: something happens within it, and this distinguishes it from a state of numbness or mechanical functioning.
This attention to experience also has consequences for how one person approaches another. The writer sees the perspective of the philosopher advocating suspension as a direct challenge to psychoanalysis, then at the height of its influence. The criticism is pointed: analysts insist on finding a precise cause for every behavior. An adult’s lack of confidence must stem from rejection by childhood peers; even chest tightness must mean that someone has failed to resolve an illicit relationship with their brother-in-law. These examples express the writer’s objection to explanations that arrive with their conclusions already determined.
The alternative the writer draws from that philosopher is to respect the thoughts people themselves choose to express and to set aside judgments formed in advance. The writer credits two later thinkers and others with developing this approach, describing it as common ground among almost all contemporary psychotherapists.
Bo Jacobsen offers a case that makes the difficulty concrete. With Christmas approaching, a female care worker visits an older man at a care home and asks where he plans to spend the holiday.
“Here,” he replies, irritable as usual.
“Then perhaps someone will come to visit you?”
No, he tells her.
She is shocked and angry. She knows he has several brothers and sisters living in nearby towns; surely at least one of them could put him up on Christmas Eve. She contacts his general practitioner, who also becomes angry and starts calling the family.
Eventually, the doctor reaches one of the man’s younger sisters. “Oh, we’d be very happy to have him,” she says. “In fact, we invited him a long time ago. But he’d rather spend Christmas alone at the care home. What can we do?”
Jacobsen describes the care worker as responsible and capable. Yet she is so certain she knows what the man wants that she sees no need to ask him carefully. Invoking the perspective of the philosopher advocating suspension, Jacobsen warns that we cannot presume to know what anyone else wants—even our partners and children. We must ask carefully and listen closely.
Perhaps the question “What is the nature of the mind?” likewise has no perfect answer waiting for us in advance, the essay’s writer suggests. We may have to arrive at our own understanding through asking and listening, again and again.
The writer closes with Planescape: Torment, calling it the most celebrated CRPG and its central question perhaps the most celebrated in gaming history. Speaking through a character, the game’s author asks: “What can change a person’s nature?” Perhaps, the writer playfully suggests, a better option to offer would be “asking and listening.”
Frequently asked questions
What does epoché mean in this essay?
Epoché means temporarily setting assumptions aside and postponing judgment so that preconceptions do not distort understanding. Matters left outside the inquiry may be returned to later; they need not be denied.
What does Bo Jacobsen’s care-home example illustrate?
The care worker assumes that the older man needs his family to host him for Christmas. His younger sister reports that the family had already invited him, but he preferred to remain alone at the care home. Jacobsen uses the case to emphasize careful questioning and listening.
Does the essay conclude that the mind has no essence?
The essay tentatively suggests that there may be no predetermined perfect answer to the mind’s nature. It proposes that understanding may emerge through repeated asking and listening.


