The Quiet Omen / Pattern Recognition

Evelyn’s Multiverse: How Time and Space Shape Perception

Explore the Kappa and Tau effects, how senses shape judgments of time and space, and what Evelyn’s multiverse story suggests about uncertainty.

Explore this hub Psychology
A woman watches unevenly spaced bulbs on a table, with one light glowing amber.

Summary

Evelyn’s alternative lives introduce an exploration of perceptual interference, three competing explanations, and the uncertainty that remains when we return to ordinary choices.

At a glance

The Kappa effect occurs when greater distance makes equal time intervals seem longer. The Tau effect reverses the direction: longer time intervals make equal distances seem greater. Their relative strength varies with sensory channel and other factors, while metaphor, magnitude, and Bayesian theories offer explanations with unresolved limitations.

Imagine lives unfolding across a multiverse: in one, you are a wealthy, acclaimed movie star; in another, a street performer spinning a pizza advertisement. Elsewhere, you inhabit a floppy world where everyone has sausages for fingers. Your own life, meanwhile, consists of running a struggling dry-cleaning business, with crises on every side.

This is the multiverse adventure of Everything Everywhere All at Once, which won several Oscars. As the barriers between universes break down, its protagonist, Evelyn, seems able to review entire alternative lives in an instant without moving from where she is. Different choices at life’s crossroads lead her toward eloping with her boyfriend or studying martial arts with a master.

In the film, Evelyn feels herself sitting in a tax office while also riding in a luxurious car surrounded by reporters. The next instant, she is a chef at a table, demonstrating elaborate meat-cutting techniques. These fictional experiences unsettle the familiar relationship between where she is and the time she seems to inhabit.

Can the perceptions we depend on be mistaken? Can our sense of time influence our sense of space, or does the influence run the other way? Two light demonstrations offer a way to explore these questions.

When distance changes duration

By the twentieth century, psychologists had identified two phenomena that reveal this interaction. In the first demonstration, bulbs arranged in a horizontal row light up one after another at equal time intervals. Yet the farther apart two bulbs are, the longer the interval between their flashes seems. This influence of spatial information on perceived time is called the Kappa effect.

In the second demonstration, the bulbs are equally spaced along a horizontal line, but the intervals between successive flashes vary. A longer interval makes the bulbs seem farther apart, even though their actual spacing remains the same. Here, temporal information influences perceived distance—a phenomenon called the Tau effect.

Together, these effects show that spatial and temporal perception can interfere with each other. Most studies report a stronger influence of spatial information on temporal judgments. Some, however, find that temporal information affects spatial judgments just as strongly, or even more strongly.

Which influence dominates depends in part on how the information reaches us. Different senses offer different levels of sensitivity to spatial and temporal information. Imagine spatial and temporal perception as two catchers, each better at catching certain kinds of balls. Greater skill at catching a particular kind of information represents greater perceptual sensitivity to it.

In experiments using visual information, such as the bulb demonstrations, researchers report relatively high spatial sensitivity and low temporal sensitivity. Temporal judgments are consequently susceptible to interference from spatial information. Some experiments use a line segment that grows at a constant rate, asking participants to attend to its length and how long it is presented.

With auditory or tactile information, the reported advantage reverses: temporal sensitivity exceeds spatial sensitivity, sometimes by a considerable margin, and the Tau effect appears. To introduce auditory information into the growing-line setup, experimenters accompany the line with a continuously presented pure tone.

The sensory channel is only one influence on the strength of interference. Others include whether images are two-dimensional or three-dimensional; stimulus salience, understood here as how readily a person can distinguish changes in a stimulus; the sources of spatial and temporal information; and perceptual sensitivity. An explanation must account for these variations as well as for the interference itself.

Three ways to explain the interaction

Psychologists have proposed several theories to explain these patterns. One is metaphor theory, which treats time as more abstract than space. In this account, our senses give us access to space, but no sense directly apprehends time. We therefore draw on concrete spatial information to describe something more abstract.

Consider how we divide time numerically into days, weeks, months, and years. Saying that March comes “before” April uses a positional relationship to express temporal order. Calling a holiday “long” borrows the idea of physical length to describe duration. Supporters of metaphor theory propose that this linguistic habit carries over into perception: because we habitually use space to express time, spatial information comes to influence our judgments of time. The asymmetry in language becomes an asymmetry in perception.

The explanation is easy to grasp, but it leaves two problems unresolved. It cannot explain findings in which temporal information influences spatial judgments more strongly than spatial information influences temporal judgments. Nor does it explain why changing the sensory channel changes the strength of interference.

Magnitude theory offers a different account. It proposes that spatial and temporal information are processed within a shared magnitude system. The two dimensions have common characteristics within that system, allowing the processing of information about one to influence the processing of the other.

A principal basis for this theory is neurobiological evidence. Brain imaging and electrophysiological studies have found partial overlap in the regions involved in spatial and temporal processing, particularly in the parietal cortex. On this basis, magnitude theory is regarded as predicting symmetric interference well: spatial information influencing temporal judgments and temporal information influencing spatial judgments to a similar degree.

Further experiments, however, have also found differences in the brain tissue involved in spatial and temporal tasks. Those differences coexist with the partial overlap, leaving magnitude theory short of a complete explanation.

Psychologists have also combined magnitude theory with Bayesian theory to develop an account of how we infer time and space jointly. Could this provide a complete explanation of their perceptual interaction?

Think of solving a math problem. You draw on the conditions given in the problem, along with formulas you know and experience with similar problems, to reach an answer. This offers an analogy for the Bayesian account of perception. Information received during an experiment corresponds to the given conditions. Your existing knowledge and experience play the role of the formulas, and your estimate of time or space is the answer that emerges from combining them.

In the bulb demonstration, for example, the observed sequence of lights provides cues to the interval between flashes. Prior experience can contribute cues too, including the familiar association between traveling a greater distance and taking more time. Within this account, the perceived interval depends on how the incoming information and prior experience come together.

How information is presented changes the relative weight given to spatial perception, temporal perception, and prior experience. In the visual bulb demonstration, relatively weak temporal sensitivity makes the incoming timing information less reliable. The perceptual estimate therefore draws more heavily on spatial information in prior experience. Greater separation between the bulbs makes the interval between their flashes seem longer, even though the actual interval remains unchanged. This is the Bayesian explanation of the Kappa effect.

Bayesian models also offer explanations for the Tau effect and for how other factors alter perceptual interference. Whether they can provide a complete explanation remains an open question, one that psychologists must investigate further.

Returning to Evelyn’s own life

Evelyn’s story offers a separate reflection on how to live with uncertainty. She can glimpse other universes and briefly take part in their lives, yet the problems in her own life still have to be addressed there.

Those alternatives have distinct attractions. The movie star’s life surrounds her with applause and honors. Her agile, capable husband from the Alpha universe excites her. The rock universe offers contemplation; the sausage-finger universe, absurdity. Each feels fresher than the life she knows.

Yet in this reading of the film, only in her own universe can Evelyn save her daughter and know the joy of her family coming together again. She begins clearing up the disorder in the shop, renews her intimacy with her husband, and lovingly tries to keep her daughter close. She prepares to file taxes again. These ordinary acts mark her return to responsibility for her own life, approached with a changed attitude and serious attention.

The perceptions we trust may fail us, and our minds sometimes wander. In an age overflowing with information, information can be both the most trustworthy thing we have and the least trustworthy.

The film repeatedly returns to chaos. That word also speaks to life in a volatile, uncertain, complex, and ambiguous era, when facing disorder and taking on challenges become part of the ordinary course of living. Difficult choices can leave us without a ready precedent to follow or a formula guaranteed to work. We cannot even glimpse a parallel universe to see how another life might unfold.

We still need the courage to try things and make choices. Accepting the world’s uncertainty also means accepting life’s unlimited possibilities.

Frequently asked questions

Does spatial information always influence time perception more strongly?

Most studies report a stronger influence of spatial information on temporal judgments. Some, however, find that temporal information affects spatial judgments just as strongly, or even more strongly.

Do Bayesian models completely explain the interaction?

Bayesian models also offer explanations for the Tau effect and for how other factors alter perceptual interference. Whether they can provide a complete explanation remains an open question, one that psychologists must investigate further.