The Quiet Omen / Life Transitions

Why Harmful Relationships Can Feel Safer Than Change

Familiar pain can feel more predictable than change. Explore fear of disruption, repeated harm, self-criticism and the possibility of support.

Explore this hub Symbolic Life
A hesitant adult reaches toward an offered hand in a quiet contemporary living room.

Summary

Keeping a relationship intact can become so important that warning signs and personal pain are pushed aside. This reflection considers how familiar suffering can erode a sense of self, and how change may bring stress alongside possibility.

At a glance

A harmful relationship may feel more predictable than the uncertainty of change, making familiar pain seem secure. This reflection explores how fear of disruption, repeated suffering, social pressure and self-criticism can deepen that attachment. It acknowledges unequal circumstances and the difficulty of leaving, while encouraging self-understanding, care for oneself and openness to support.

Why might someone hesitate to change a life that makes them unhappy? A reflection on a book on principles for living brings that question into relationships: why do people become increasingly trapped in harmful ones, and how can they preserve themselves within one? Its starting point is a troubling possibility: a life can feel terrible and still feel stable.

Chaos can take familiar forms. Imagine staring at the to-do list on your work computer, overwhelmed by five tasks, every one marked “very important,” with no idea where to begin. Or imagine the agitation of WeChat messages arriving one after another: “Why aren’t you replying?” “Where are you? What are you doing?” “Call me back!”

There is also the stunned confusion that might follow an unexpected slap across the face. For a moment, you cannot think; the world seems to darken around you. These situations differ, but each offers a glimpse of what it can feel like to lose your bearings.

A passage quoted in the reflection gives chaos and order a vivid contrast:

Chaos is ignorance and the unknown: the rustling of grass at night, the despair and fear you feel after a profound betrayal, the world after it has collapsed, the end of dreams, a career, or a marriage. Order, by contrast, is explored territory: stable relationships, the social masks people wear, the plans for today.

The writer reasons that this frightening prospect of uncertainty draws us toward something we can count on. We long for stable relationships and patterns that stay the same. But we may mistake whatever we currently live with for order and imagine that changing it would bring chaos.

Even being beaten every day, frequently humiliated, or distressed by the same recurring issue can come to feel more secure than change simply because we know what to expect. Leaving things as they are may seem the safest, most stable response, though that sense of security does not make the situation safe.

Once keeping the relationship intact feels like the most necessary and safest priority, recognizing danger may no longer be enough to make us act. We may notice warning signs and still compromise, give way, and swallow our anger or distress to protect the relationship and the false appearance of order it provides.

If people mock and ridicule you for expressing yourself online, might you imagine that answering back—or saying, “Let them think what they want”—would damage your public image far more than it actually would? You might put your phone away without a word and sit alone with the hurt.

The first time your husband or wife takes their anger out on you through verbal abuse or even a beating, might you worry that asking friends or relatives for help would invite gossip? Might calling the police seem, to you, like making too much of it? Those fears could leave you enduring the abuse, forgiving your spouse, or pretending it does not matter to you.

Or suppose you are unhappy in a romantic relationship. Every conversation feels oppressive, and you do not even want to see your partner. Might you overestimate the upheaval that leaving would bring, while also fearing that your partner would keep pursuing you and refuse to let go? Faced with those possibilities, you might grit your teeth and continue to endure their control and humiliation.

The writer rejects the idea that fearing upheaval or finding it difficult to leave proves someone is weak, unintelligent, or unable to think for themselves. In this account, susceptibility to these pressures is a vulnerability we share as social animals.

People who have escaped a harmful relationship and now feel unafraid of chaos deserve recognition for their courage. They also have reason to acknowledge the part luck may have played: the relationship they escaped may not have been as difficult to leave as someone else’s. Their experience cannot be the measure of how easily another person should be able to get out.

The question is also why destructive experiences keep repeating. A passage quoted by the writer credits a theorist with the term “repetition compulsion” for the repetition of painful past experiences. The passage offers several possible explanations: people may be trying to understand the past and gain a sense of control; circumstances may leave them little choice; or they may have lost the capacity to break out of the pattern.

The writer then considers how repetition can make daily life feel manageable. As routines become automatic habits, they can reduce complexity and make life more predictable. Striving, self-discipline, and hard work can become familiar patterns. So can the experience of being subjected to domestic abuse or humiliation, even though the person suffering it has not chosen the harm.

In this account, predictability can create an illusion of stability that gradually erodes a person’s judgment, ability to act, and courage to change. Being worn down begins to feel ordinary. Pain becomes familiar enough to pass for order.

That familiarity may be reinforced by the explanations a person gives themselves. Within a controlling relationship, catering to a partner’s preferences may begin to feel like a sign of maturity. Sacrifice may seem a necessary part of learning to live together. A person might reason that everyone has extreme tendencies, and that being a good partner means understanding and accepting those parts of the other person.

In trying so hard to be “good,” they may overlook their own pain and forget that the person they most need to care for first may be themselves. As they keep making accommodations to preserve the relationship’s stability and prevent it from breaking apart, they may gradually lose their sense of who they are.

That loss of self may find a voice in harsh comparisons: “Unlike most people, I’m no longer ‘pure.’ I’m not good enough.” Or: “Compared with most people, I haven’t satisfied the people whose approval matters to me. I’m not good enough.” Or: “Other people have happy families. Mine is unhappy, so I must be a bad partner.” These are accusations someone may turn against themselves, not proof of their inadequacy.

Another passage quoted in the reflection offers a possible explanation for this susceptibility to comparison:

When people are young, they may lack independence and understanding because they have not yet accumulated experience and wisdom or developed firm personal standards. They turn to comparisons with others and are swayed by their surroundings. An inner critic emerges, noisy and relentless, continually condemning them.

Understanding these pressures does not yield a simple way out. The writer acknowledges how difficult it is to offer a sequence of steps—one, two, three—that would reliably help someone preserve themselves in a harmful relationship. Instead, the reflection draws on a point attributed to a scholar, introduced as teaching social psychology at Beijing Normal University: recognizing that our social environment can influence us, even dominate us, does not make us contemptible. Seeing our human vulnerabilities should help us face ourselves and work toward change, rather than condemn ourselves.

Recognizing how the desire to keep a relationship stable can draw us further into harm also gives us something to remember. The writer suggests setting an alarm as a reminder: do not magnify the terror of disruption, and keep loving the ordinary but unique person you are.

A further passage quoted in the reflection holds stress and possibility together:

As life moves forward, you may find yourself in temporary chaos. It can bring stress, but also new hope.

The writer develops this thought: being thrown off an established path may also loosen the grip of fixed assumptions, whether your own or other people’s. Leaving a familiar order does not always mean rising from the ashes into a transformed life. Yet staying in an already harmful order and repeatedly sacrificing yourself to fit it can carry a cumulative cost. The writer compares those seemingly small sacrifices to a virus spreading through cells and organs, gradually consuming the person—a picture of how those losses can, over time, destroy your sense of self.

If you still cannot find the courage, consider reaching out a hand. There may be people willing to take it and help you find a way out. Allow yourself to believe in that possibility.