
Summary
A graduation dilemma opens a discussion of rewards, social expectations and conditional self-worth, leading to reflective questions about emotional experience and the support needed for more autonomous choices.
At a glance
The article proposes examining external pressures, conditional self-worth and the needs behind our emotions when making difficult choices. Seeking support for autonomy, competence and connection may help sustain interest and make choices more autonomous. This approach does not promise immediate wealth, a suitable job or a completed thesis.
Graduate school, the autumn recruitment season, going abroad—which direction should you take?
Picture a dorm room at 10 p.m. Three students are comparing their options.
“I rushed to two interviews today,” A says. “Neither worked out. Rejected again.”
B still hasn't found a job. “Maybe I should settle down and prepare for the postgraduate entrance exams. But I really don't want to.”
C has two offers and a different dilemma. “One is from a large company with a ‘997’ schedule. The other is from a smaller organization. The workload is lighter, but the pay is so much lower.”
The scene is set in pandemic-era 2020, when people were facing greater uncertainty and trying to choose amid disruption. How should we choose when we feel this torn? And why does a particular option draw us toward it?
The writer who offers this illustrative scene suggests that Edward Deci's book on intrinsic motivation may offer some answers, identifying Deci as the founder of self-determination theory. The discussion begins with the difference between doing something out of interest and doing it for an external reward.
When rewards become control
The writer recounts a riddle experiment conducted by Deci. Participants were divided into three experimental groups, separate from the students in the opening scene. Before the activity began, experimental group A was told that successfully solving the riddles would earn a reward. Group B learned only after the activity that they would receive money for successful solving. Group C received no reward.
Afterward, participants were asked to stay at the venue for a while and could spend that time as they wished. Those in group A rarely returned to the riddles, apparently having lost interest. Participants in group C remained interested and continued solving.
The writer interprets this pattern as a weakening of some participants' intrinsic motivation by monetary rewards. Beyond this experiment, the writer reports that many studies suggest external control used as an incentive may impair performance on tasks requiring deep concentration or creativity.
That argument leaves room for rewards to be useful. Moderate rewards and control can improve performance, the writer acknowledges, pointing to piecework pay in the early industrial era, pay linked to effort, and high salaries paired with “996” work schedules. The concern is what happens when control becomes excessive: existing interest in the work may erode. Behavior directed toward obtaining a reward may continue only while that reward is expected. Some people may also take shortcuts, deceive or manipulate to secure the return.
When expectations become conditions of worth
Control can also take the form of social “musts” and “shoulds.” In the writer's account, each stage of growing up seems to bring things we are expected to do. Departing from those expectations can invite judgments that we are bad, abnormal or failing to follow an accepted path through life. As we internalize these beliefs, our sense of worth can become increasingly dependent on external conditions: what others think of us, the status of our employer or how much we earn.
The writer describes ego involvement as arising when these internalized beliefs become firmly held and our worth depends on meeting their conditions. A man whose sense of worth depends on his work, for example, becomes ego-involved in work; a woman whose sense of worth depends on her family becomes ego-involved in family matters. In each example, the relationship is conditional: a particular part of life has become the basis of the person's worth.
Turning to research on ego involvement, the writer reports that many studies link it to weaker intrinsic motivation for tasks and greater performance-related pressure, tension and anxiety. The accompanying explanation is that people come to act to meet external expectations rather than from a spontaneous willingness to do the activity itself.
When respect depends on behaving a certain way, people may force themselves to perform that way in front of others, losing interest and enthusiasm in the process. The writer argues that this sustains a false self while obstructing the development of an authentic one.
Examining those conditions begins with questions about the beliefs and rules we feel we “should” follow. Do I really need to obey this particular rule? Is this activity necessary? How strong is my own intrinsic motivation to do it?
Finding support in our surroundings
Those questions also direct attention to the conditions around us. The writer's first practical proposal concerns environmental support: an environment can offer opportunities to develop, or it can undermine intrinsic motivation. The examples return to pandemic-era 2020—workers enduring unfair treatment and students silently accepting unreasonable demands from academic supervisors.
Even when alternatives seem absent, the writer suggests that acting on our own initiative may help us obtain more support. Exchanging suggestions with colleagues, for instance, can foster a sense of competence, autonomy and connection with others at work. That connection may allow more positive feedback to pass between people, strengthening intrinsic motivation and making them more willing to act.
When connection cannot be established, however, or the environment is manipulative or psychologically harmful, the writer urges people to seek help from others promptly or move to a different environment.
Making room for emotional reactions
Alongside environmental support, the writer proposes examining how ego involvement shapes emotional reactions. Consider someone who can feel worthy only when others see them as strong. Being seen as vulnerable may then threaten their sense of worth, provoking rage or even a feeling that their survival is at stake.
But is that evaluation truly a threat? Must we be strong, gentle or creative—or earn extraordinary amounts of money—to have worth?
The proposal is to loosen the connection between particular traits and our sense of self, so that changes in those traits no longer threaten who we are. A little of an “I don't care” attitude toward judgments that define our worth in this way might reduce sensitivity to evaluation and make emotions easier to manage.
Examining ego involvement can create room to observe our reactions with curiosity. What is happening within us when a judgment feels so threatening? The writer suggests that this space can help us find ways to ease excessive reactions and avoid being wholly controlled by emotion. It offers a way to regulate emotions and act more autonomously while still allowing ourselves to feel them.
For A, B and C in the opening dorm-room scene, graduation brings conflict, hesitation and the discomfort of beginning life beyond university. They can ask themselves, “What do I need?” And, when drawn toward a particular option, “Do I truly need it?”
The writer suggests using emotions as clues to an inner need for autonomy. That requires feeling them more fully rather than suppressing them. Autonomy here includes giving ourselves permission to experience our emotions and accepting ourselves more fully. Self-acceptance and attention to our inner experience become starting points for change.
Such a change may not make us wealthy, immediately lead us to a suitable job or get our thesis written. The proposed benefit is a growing sense of lightness and clarity as we continue carrying life's burdens.
The writer places these decisions against a short historical backdrop: humanity entered the industrial age only a few centuries ago, yet rapid social development seems to demand major choices immediately. Increasingly, those choices are judged by external conditions—money, fame and socially imposed standards.
The concluding argument is that satisfying our basic psychological needs for autonomy, competence and connection is necessary for intrinsic motivation, sustained interest in learning and work, and an autonomous, happy life. In this view, external measures of success cannot substitute for those needs.
Frequently asked questions
Do rewards always weaken intrinsic motivation?
The writer acknowledges that moderate rewards and control can improve performance. The concern is that excessive control may erode existing interest and make continued action depend on an expected reward.
Does greater autonomy require suppressing emotions?
The article proposes feeling emotions more fully rather than suppressing them. It presents emotional awareness and self-acceptance as starting points for change, without promising immediate financial, career or academic success.


