
Summary
Deciding to forgive and experiencing emotional forgiveness differ. Two reported studies examine that distinction through memory for peripheral details, psychological distance, and the central facts that remain.
At a glance
In the reported studies, emotional forgiveness was linked to greater forgetting of noncentral details of hurtful events; the findings did not extend to central details. Deciding to forgive without an emotional change did not show the same pattern. Researchers proposed that psychological distance and abstract understanding could help explain the relationship. Forgiveness remains optional and is not necessary for recovery.
“To err is human; to forgive, divine.” —Alexander Pope
Forgiveness can be a precious gift to our inner lives. Yet after someone has hurt us deeply, how do we move beyond the experience and continue with our lives?
Researchers at the UK's De Montfort University explored how forgiveness relates to deliberately trying to forget unpleasant experiences. Their research, reported in January 2021 in the Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, distinguished between deciding to forgive and experiencing a change in feeling toward the person responsible.
Intentional forgetting means actively suppressing memories of unpleasant experiences in an effort to forget a painful past. It may ease some of the negative emotions associated with those experiences. Forgiveness has also been found to help reduce negative emotions, though neither approach guarantees relief.
Forgiveness is not necessary to move beyond those feelings. Some people who have been hurt do not want to forgive; others cannot. It remains a choice, not a requirement for recovery.
For those who do choose forgiveness, the distinction between its two forms matters. Decisional forgiveness means deciding to forgive and forgoing revenge even while resentment remains. A person may also try to maintain the relationship, though that is not a requirement. The decision concerns how to act; it does not necessarily change how the person feels. Emotional forgiveness involves that emotional change: letting go of negative feelings toward the person responsible and replacing them with positive ones.
In the first study, participants imagined discovering that their partner had been unfaithful just before they were due to move in together. They were then encouraged to forget details associated with this imagined betrayal, including a list of adjectives describing the partner.
One group received instructions intended to encourage emotional forgiveness: wish the partner positive or healing experiences and focus their thoughts and feelings on compassion. Another group received decisional-forgiveness instructions: recognize that the partner had behaved badly, but decide against retaliation and choose to treat them positively. A comparison group received no instructions to forgive.
The researchers found greater forgetting of noncentral details in the emotional-forgiveness group than in either of the other groups. That difference did not extend to the central details of the betrayal. Participants in the emotional-forgiveness group also reported feeling greater psychological distance from the imagined wrongdoing.
The next study moved from imagined betrayal to participants' own experiences. In the first reported online session, participants wrote detailed accounts of events in which another person had deeply offended or hurt them and which still stirred anger or resentment. They then rated several aspects of the experience, including how much they had forgiven the person responsible.
A second session followed 7 to 11 days later, using the same three conditions: emotional-forgiveness instructions, decisional-forgiveness instructions, and a comparison condition without instructions to forgive.
Here, too, emotional forgiveness, rather than decisional forgiveness, was associated with greater forgetting of noncentral details. The association did not extend to central details. Emotional forgiveness was also associated with a change in how much participants reported forgiving the person who had hurt them.
To explain this pattern, the researchers proposed that emotional forgiveness makes the wrongdoing feel more psychologically distant. That distance allows the person who was hurt to understand the event more abstractly, retaining its main points without remembering every detail. In their explanation, this more abstract understanding strengthens intentional forgetting, which in turn encourages greater emotional forgiveness. The two could thus reinforce each other in a beneficial cycle while the central facts remain intact.
The writer reporting these studies draws a practical recommendation from this explanation: when someone chooses forgiveness as a way of coping with hurt, it should take an emotional form. This recommendation remains conditional on that choice; people need not forgive in order to recover.
The writer also describes the research as the first exploration of intentional forgetting in relation to both emotional and decisional forgiveness. Its contribution brings together the reported increases in psychological distance and abstract understanding with the link between intentional forgetting and subsequent forgiveness.
Whether repeated intentional forgetting might lead to greater forgiveness remains an open question. Exploring it could help researchers understand how to design interventions that resolve conflict and support psychological adjustment and reconciliation afterward.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between emotional and decisional forgiveness?
Decisional forgiveness means deciding to forgive and forgoing revenge even while resentment remains. Emotional forgiveness involves letting go of negative feelings toward the person responsible and replacing them with positive ones. Maintaining the relationship is not a requirement.
Does emotional forgiveness erase the central details of wrongdoing?
The reported forgetting findings concerned noncentral details. They did not extend to central details of the wrongdoing.
Is forgiveness necessary to recover from being hurt?
Forgiveness is not necessary for recovery. Some people do not want to forgive; others cannot. It remains a choice.
Can repeated intentional forgetting increase forgiveness?
Whether repeated intentional forgetting might lead to greater forgiveness remains an open question.

